best way to get MP3 into radio?

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by trs80, Jul 30, 2005.

  1. trs80

    trs80 Guest

    I have a 2003 Odyssey. It has a radio with cd player. What is the best way
    to get a mp3 player into the audio system? Is there a good phase locked FM
    transmitter to use? I got a cheap FM transmitter that plugs in to lighter
    but its really crappy and drifts of station every few minutes.

    any thoughts?
    r
     
    trs80, Jul 30, 2005
    #1
  2. trs80

    Milleron Guest

    There are kits available to allow a direct cable connection to your
    radio. I think these kits won't work if you have the Navigation
    system built in, but I could be wrong. Unless you're handy enough to
    install them yourself, they're going to cost you well over $100. You
    can Google for threads describing these, but here's one example:
    http://www.myradiostore.us/auxadapters/pie/factory/no-external-changer/hon03-pc-son.html

    The reason I'm responding, though, is to say that you might want to
    consider trying one or two more FM transmitters before going to the
    expense and trouble of installing a jack on the radio. Your
    experience is perfectly typical because most of these FM transmitters
    do not work well. Currently, I found a thing for my daughter's iPod
    Mini, however, that works very well, indeed. It's called the PODFM by
    Macally and it was only $35. The important factors in these
    transmitters are that they get their power from the car's 12V outlet,
    as opposed to the MP3 player's batteries, and that they're designed
    well. Your first one apparently got one out of two. I've heard that
    the units from Belkin are often problematic, but that the ones from
    Griffin are generally a little better. Anyway, if you find a good one
    right off the bat, you can save $100 and have a solution that's
    portable from vehicle to vehicle and doesn't have to go with your
    Odyssey when you sell it. It might be worth the gamble of trying a
    different one.


    Ron
     
    Milleron, Jul 30, 2005
    #2
  3. trs80

    dold Guest

    The FM transmitters are junk. They introduce hiss if they work at all.

    There is an empty connector on the back of my 2003 Civic single-CD.
    This is intended for a cassette or CD changer, but the P.I.E adapter plugs
    in there. My MP3 player appears as a CD changer that's always on disc one
    track one. The audio is far superior to the FM adapter.

    http://www.logjamelectronics.com/piehon98aux.html
    PIE HON98-AUX Auxiliary Input Converter
     
    dold, Jul 30, 2005
    #3
  4. trs80

    dold Guest

    The FM transmitters are junk. They introduce hiss if they work at all.

    There is an empty connector on the back of my 2003 Civic single-CD.
    This is intended for a cassette or CD changer, but the P.I.E adapter plugs
    in there. My MP3 player appears as a CD changer that's always on disc one
    track one. The audio is far superior to the FM adapter.

    http://www.logjamelectronics.com/piehon98aux.html
    PIE HON98-AUX Auxiliary Input Converter
     
    dold, Jul 30, 2005
    #4
  5. Have you successfully integrated a Music Keg? You Say it sees a changer
    always showing disc 1 and track 1. I am currently looking for a way to
    integrate mine to the factory audio system. I have a couple of Kenwood head
    units but they won't look right
    Shaun
     
    Shaun Matherly, Jul 31, 2005
    #5
  6. trs80

    Guest Guest

    Ive been using the iTrip FM xmitter with the iPod, and it just .. works.
    Its easy, and the quality is great. Just a little tip there. Otherwise -
    just swap out the headunit with one that plays MP3.
     
    Guest, Jul 31, 2005
    #6
  7. trs80

    Seth Guest

    Contact www.phatnoise.com. They make the "PhatBox" (same thing as the
    Kenwood Music Keg) and sell systems specific to many cars, including Civics
    with CD changer controls in the radio. They could tell you if their
    adapters will work with your specific music keg and sell you the adapters.
     
    Seth, Jul 31, 2005
    #7
  8. trs80

    slim Guest

    iPod and Belkin FM Transmitter,

    --
    "I'm the commander -- see, I don't need to explain --
    I do not need to explain why I say things. That's the
    interesting thing about being the president.
    Maybe somebody needs to explain to me why they
    say something, but I don't feel like I owe anybody
    an explanation. "
    - George "Dubya" Bush
     
    slim, Jul 31, 2005
    #8
  9. trs80

    Pars Guest

    I've found that my $10 Tape Adapter works great. Probably better then any FM
    transmitter on the market. The head/tape unit is Alpine, which might also
    contribute to the the amazing sound quality.

    Pars
     
    Pars, Aug 2, 2005
    #9
  10. trs80

    Sam Nickaby Guest

    I'd never tried the iPod transmitter but FM transmitters have limitations. It
    won't cover the 15Khz range very well. Tape adapter does it better. But the
    best sound quality will come from line input.
     
    Sam Nickaby, Aug 2, 2005
    #10
  11. I'd go with an affordable CD unit with an auxiliary input on the face.
    Wait 'til Best Buy or such has a free installation sale. That FM stuff
    is open to too much interference.
     
    merlotbrougham, Aug 3, 2005
    #11
  12. trs80

    dold Guest

    He already has a CD player with an aux input on the back, or would, with an
    adapter that costs less than a new head unit.
    http://www.logjamelectronics.com/piehon98aux.html
    1999-2004 CR-V and Odyssey
     
    dold, Aug 3, 2005
    #12
  13. trs80

    Milleron Guest

    All true, but many of us no longer have tape players, and installation
    of a line input can be pricey, if it's even possible. That's why the
    FM transmitters will continue to be a consideration . . . and why the
    search goes on for a good one.


    Ron
     
    Milleron, Aug 4, 2005
    #13
  14. trs80

    Milleron Guest

    Great tip for many owners. There are lots of us, though that have no
    tape player and either a Navigation system or an in-dash CD changer,
    both of which are deal busters for the P.I.E. part.

    Does anyone have a suggestion for getting a line-in for a Honda Navi
    with CD changer?

    Ron
     
    Milleron, Aug 4, 2005
    #14
  15. trs80

    dold Guest

    You mentioned price in an earlier post.
    The PIE adapter was $49.95. The Belkin was $29.95, and the iTrip $34.95.
    For the difference in quality, I don't think that's a big difference.

    I still have the Belkin, which I would take with me on a trip for use in a
    rental car. It doesn't work at all in some vehicles.
    If you have an iPod, there are PIE adapters that integrate fully.

    The piehon98aux works with some Nav units, in spite of their earlier
    cautions against it.
    http://logjam.d3datasolutions.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=45

    It boils down to three cases. Some Nav units occupy the 14 pin connector,
    but don't use the pins that PIE uses, so they offer a Y connector.
    Some Nav units don't use the 14 pin connector, so it's empty and available.
    Some Nav units are not compatible.

    If you have a changer, there are active units that "tee" into the
    connectors and work with those as well.
     
    dold, Aug 4, 2005
    #15
  16. trs80

    Milleron Guest

    The price of the part is not the point. For those of us who cannot
    install the adapter ourselves, the cost of the hardware is a minor
    part of the total expense.
    Navigation systems with 6-CD changers are not all the same? Honda
    uses different ones in different models?
    I guess I'll just have to find a car audio shop somewhere (my city's
    not big enough to have one unless you include Best Buy) and ask them
    if they can give me a line-in and what the cost is.

    Ron
     
    Milleron, Aug 4, 2005
    #16
  17. trs80

    dold Guest

    I put mine in myself. I had to take out a couple of plastic panels and
    reach up blindly behind the radio, locating the 14 pin connector by feel,
    but it wasn't hard, and required no particular talent.
    Apparently so. The logjam forum even argues that point, something like
    "hey, the radio is the same from 1999-2004, why is the 2001 listed
    separately?".
    I had no luck finding one in a retail shop. They all like the FM
    transmitters, or maybe the FM widgets that actually plug in to the antenna
    line, which I suppose works better than the free-air FM transmitter.
     
    dold, Aug 4, 2005
    #17
  18. trs80

    Milleron Guest

    OK! Thanks for the tip.

    snip
    I didn't know about the "widgets." That sounds as though it would
    surely give FM quality, which is plenty good enough for me, and it
    sounds as though installation would be much simpler and less
    expensive.

    Thanks again.

    Ron
     
    Milleron, Aug 6, 2005
    #18
  19. trs80

    dold Guest

    http://makeashorterlink.com/?C1D73243B
    remove the standard Honda stereo - Dold - rec.autos.maker.honda
     
    dold, Aug 6, 2005
    #19
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.