Big 3 Bust Implications

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by Vic Smith, Dec 13, 2008.

  1. Vic Smith

    Vic Smith Guest

    You know - unintended consequences.
    Lots of social/economy related stuff.
    But also much related to limiting competition.
    Possibilities:
    Toyota/Honda et all jack up prices.
    Toyota/Honda et all attempt to lower wages.
    UAW gets the vote at transplant sites.
    All kinds of interesting possibilities.
    Anybody care to speculate?

    --Vic
     
    Vic Smith, Dec 13, 2008
    #1
  2. Vic Smith

    Jeff Guest

    The Michigan 3 (they aren't the big 3 anymore - Toyota is bigger than
    GM worldwide; some call them the Detroit 3 - but they aren't all based
    in Detroit) will reorganize under bankruptcy protection just like the
    airlines did. UAW will be forced to eat consessions.
     
    Jeff, Dec 13, 2008
    #2
  3. Vic Smith

    L Alpert Guest

    The Michigan 3 (they aren't the big 3 anymore - Toyota is bigger than
    GM worldwide; some call them the Detroit 3 - but they aren't all based
    in Detroit) will reorganize under bankruptcy protection just like the
    airlines did. UAW will be forced to eat consessions.
     
    L Alpert, Dec 13, 2008
    #3
  4. Vic Smith

    Gosi Guest

    Adios tp big bonuses and lousy management.

    Hello to new technology and rebirth of progress
     
    Gosi, Dec 13, 2008
    #4
  5. Vic Smith

    edspyhill01 Guest

    A wet dream for all republicans, especially the johnny reb
    republicans. You guys won't be happy until everybody sports missing
    teeth and marries their cousin or bloodhound. Careful what you wish
    for. The economy of the south will be worse that the post-civil war
    economy. Once you bozos bust the UAW the auto workers in foreign non-
    union shops are going to plummet.
     
    edspyhill01, Dec 13, 2008
    #5
  6. Vic Smith

    Elle Guest

    Their pensions have long been guaranteed by the federal
    government. This is one of the reasons why a bailout was
    said to be cheaper.
     
    Elle, Dec 13, 2008
    #6
  7. Vic Smith

    Jeff Guest

    Actually, the pensions are only guaranteed to a certain limit,
    determined, in part, by their age at retirement

    In addition, the other retiree benefits, like health insurance, are
    not guarenteed.

    Jeff
     
    Jeff, Dec 13, 2008
    #7
  8. Vic Smith

    Elle Guest

    The details of what each Big 3 retiree blah blah would
    receive is so nuanced that I was only trying to convey that
    the cost will be huge. For elaboration on how much is
    guaranteed, see the wiki entry
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pension_Benefit_Guaranty_Corporation
    Actually, if one is an eligible PBGC pension recipient, then
    one gets a sizable tax credit for their health insurance
    premium, again costing the taxpayer money.
     
    Elle, Dec 13, 2008
    #8
  9. Vic Smith

    News Guest


    And what exactly is your point? "Costing the taxpayer money" blah blah
    blah.

    Why not go after corporate tax gamers/cheats based in Bermuda, Caymans,
    Dubai, et al?

    Sell anything to Honda today? Toyota? Oh, too bad...
     
    News, Dec 13, 2008
    #9
  10. Vic Smith

    Vic Smith Guest

    It might surprise some that the gov will pick up the pensions, but
    there it is. Didn't know about the med tax credit.
    I've heard that the GM pension costs are or about to be severed from
    GM's books.
    Actual facts about financial details are hard to come by.
    Really think Corker has the best and most objective view of the
    details.
    It's my impression - and it's only an impression - that bankruptcy of
    any of the Big 3 will cost the taxpayer and economy many times more
    than the solution that has been proposed by Congress.
    But that doesn't matter if you hate GM or UAW.
    THEY HAVE TO DIE!
    DIE! DIE!
    heh heh

    --Vic
     
    Vic Smith, Dec 13, 2008
    #10
  11. Vic Smith

    L Alpert Guest

    The individuals that were counting on promised pensions to carry them
    through retirement are the biggest losers. Lousy management types are
    usually rewarded new positions through some type of crony-ism.....
     
    L Alpert, Dec 13, 2008
    #11
  12. Vic Smith

    SoCalMike Guest


    i dont see honda/toyota/nissan rocking the boat. they pay well enough,
    and theyll continue to do so. theyve always priced slightly higher than
    american cars on average, but you get what you pay for, generally. not
    so much to be said for the german automakers.

    and theres always hyundai/kia to consider as well. theyre not as crappy
    as they were before.
     
    SoCalMike, Dec 13, 2008
    #12
  13. Vic Smith

    SoCalMike Guest


    the first thing GM will do will be to give upper management HUGE bonuses
    for all their smart "cost-cutting efforts", which is exactly what roger
    smith did after moving plants to meh-hee-co.
     
    SoCalMike, Dec 13, 2008
    #13
  14. Vic Smith

    Tim Guest

    How much do you think Honda and Toyota would pay if the UAW hadn't
    established $28/hr contracts for the Big Three?
     
    Tim, Dec 13, 2008
    #14
  15. Vic Smith

    Dioclese Guest

    Something that's been brewing in my mind since finding out that Ford is
    faring better that the other 2 U.S. automakers. If G.M./Chrysler go
    bankrupt soon, Ford will be okay for awhile. After the BR proceedings and
    retooling etc., G.M. and Chrysler will have an distinct advantage with lack
    of any previous liabilities including previous warrantes on their previous
    products for instance. Ford will still carry all its previous liabilities..
    This will probably result in a unfair result in an apparent non-competive
    U.S. marketplace per bankruptcy proceedings future results. Ford, as a
    result, will be at a disadvantage carrying all its baggage to compete with 1
    or 2 U.S.leaner competitors.

    To me, this is extremely obvious. Haven't seen this observation on any U.S.
    news media commentary or politico. Let alone, the Ford CEO himself.

    As a result, I believe its beneficial for Ford to intentionally go bankrupt
    to remain competitive in the long run. That, depending on future
    developments, may be Ford's intention. Go figure....
    --
    Dave

    2008 Focus , 5 spd no frills coupe- to date per fillup - 33 mpg low - 39 mpg
    high.

    How much CO footprint to remove and transport basic materials for batteries
    and to manufacture the batteries for the Ford Focus and any other hybrid?
     
    Dioclese, Dec 15, 2008
    #15
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.