Carfax?

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by Elle, Sep 24, 2009.

  1. Elle

    jim beam Guest

    paying full coverage insurance on an old vehicle is a fools game.
    premiums outweigh the vehicle worth very quickly - and you lose your
    vehicle in the event of all but the teeniest fender bender. save the
    money and just get third party. then you can make your own decision on
    whether to repair, and pay for it out of your savings.
     
    jim beam, Sep 28, 2009
    #41
  2. Elle

    AZ Nomad Guest

    It is still useful information.
     
    AZ Nomad, Sep 28, 2009
    #42
  3. Elle

    AZ Nomad Guest

    It is still useful information.
     
    AZ Nomad, Sep 28, 2009
    #43
  4. Elle

    jim beam Guest

    how? it can't be relied on for proof of condition, either good or bad.
    why would you spend the money on carfax when you can spend it on
    something reliable i.e. physical inspection?
     
    jim beam, Sep 28, 2009
    #44
  5. Elle

    jim beam Guest

    how? it can't be relied on for proof of condition, either good or bad.
    why would you spend the money on carfax when you can spend it on
    something reliable i.e. physical inspection?
     
    jim beam, Sep 28, 2009
    #45
  6. Elle

    AZ Nomad Guest

    If you have the knowledge, you can act on it. This is really basic
    stuff. Ignorance isn't bliss.
     
    AZ Nomad, Sep 28, 2009
    #46
  7. Elle

    AZ Nomad Guest

    If you have the knowledge, you can act on it. This is really basic
    stuff. Ignorance isn't bliss.
     
    AZ Nomad, Sep 28, 2009
    #47
  8. Elle

    jim beam Guest

    indeed, ignorance isn't bliss. but with carfax, the ignorance not only
    remains, but one can be misled.
     
    jim beam, Sep 28, 2009
    #48
  9. Elle

    jim beam Guest

    indeed, ignorance isn't bliss. but with carfax, the ignorance not only
    remains, but one can be misled.
     
    jim beam, Sep 28, 2009
    #49
  10. Elle

    Elle Guest

    Perhaps you may not believe a Carfax (or autocheck.com) report that
    shows either (1) five owners in ten years (though the seller says he
    is the only owner); or (2) odometer tampering; or (3) a salvage
    vehicle. I would rely on such information. Hence for my purposes, any
    of these would rule out the car for me. If the Carfax comes up clean
    on these points, then there is still doubt in my mind, but less so.
    Remember how KBB values a vehicle as well, and that KBB tends to be
    the standard for valuing a vehicle. Any title that is a "salvage"
    title or shows odometer tampering means the car cannot be valued in
    KBB's eyes. You can call people ridiculous for not being interested in
    a salvage vehicle or a vehicle with unknown mileage, but these people
    are a large part of the car buying market. What they say rules when it
    comes time to sell a car.

    On insurance, the premium goes towards more than just damage to one's
    vehicle. Sure consider the value of the car, and your deductible, when
    reviewing that part of the premium going towards paying for damage to
    one's vehicle. But one cannot just compute the annual premium, note it
    will exceed the value of the car in X months, and say one is
    overpaying for insurance.
     
    Elle, Sep 28, 2009
    #50
  11. Elle

    Elle Guest

    Perhaps you may not believe a Carfax (or autocheck.com) report that
    shows either (1) five owners in ten years (though the seller says he
    is the only owner); or (2) odometer tampering; or (3) a salvage
    vehicle. I would rely on such information. Hence for my purposes, any
    of these would rule out the car for me. If the Carfax comes up clean
    on these points, then there is still doubt in my mind, but less so.
    Remember how KBB values a vehicle as well, and that KBB tends to be
    the standard for valuing a vehicle. Any title that is a "salvage"
    title or shows odometer tampering means the car cannot be valued in
    KBB's eyes. You can call people ridiculous for not being interested in
    a salvage vehicle or a vehicle with unknown mileage, but these people
    are a large part of the car buying market. What they say rules when it
    comes time to sell a car.

    On insurance, the premium goes towards more than just damage to one's
    vehicle. Sure consider the value of the car, and your deductible, when
    reviewing that part of the premium going towards paying for damage to
    one's vehicle. But one cannot just compute the annual premium, note it
    will exceed the value of the car in X months, and say one is
    overpaying for insurance.
     
    Elle, Sep 28, 2009
    #51
  12. Elle

    jim beam Guest

    what does the number of owners matter??? you only need one careless one
    to screw a vehicle up.

    what does that really matter? inspection will show if the vehicle has
    been properly maintained. you only need one careless...

    i don't get the problem with salvage. sure, some can be garbage, but
    that shows up on inspection.

    fyi, my crx is salvage. the one prior lady owner had turned it in for
    the $600 california dmv clunker fee, and the junkyard wheeled it into
    their "whole vehicles" pound, then immediately sold it to me for $1000.
    the vehicle is all original, excellent condition [apart from paint
    because it lived outside], and well maintained. it's straighter than a
    vehicle damaged on the dealer's lot and repaired before first
    registration. but it's "salvage" because it had been de-registered.

    that's like people wanting "natural" diamond vs lab-grown diamond. if
    the latter is still crystallized carbon, flawless, cheaper, and doesn't
    come smeared in blood, i see absolutely no problem with it, yet the
    brainwashed masses think otherwise.

    why not? i don't understand why paying more to /not/ own your own
    vehicle in the event of an accident makes sense.
     
    jim beam, Sep 29, 2009
    #52
  13. Elle

    jim beam Guest

    what does the number of owners matter??? you only need one careless one
    to screw a vehicle up.

    what does that really matter? inspection will show if the vehicle has
    been properly maintained. you only need one careless...

    i don't get the problem with salvage. sure, some can be garbage, but
    that shows up on inspection.

    fyi, my crx is salvage. the one prior lady owner had turned it in for
    the $600 california dmv clunker fee, and the junkyard wheeled it into
    their "whole vehicles" pound, then immediately sold it to me for $1000.
    the vehicle is all original, excellent condition [apart from paint
    because it lived outside], and well maintained. it's straighter than a
    vehicle damaged on the dealer's lot and repaired before first
    registration. but it's "salvage" because it had been de-registered.

    that's like people wanting "natural" diamond vs lab-grown diamond. if
    the latter is still crystallized carbon, flawless, cheaper, and doesn't
    come smeared in blood, i see absolutely no problem with it, yet the
    brainwashed masses think otherwise.

    why not? i don't understand why paying more to /not/ own your own
    vehicle in the event of an accident makes sense.
     
    jim beam, Sep 29, 2009
    #53
  14. Elle

    Elle Guest

    Jim, I think your goals for owning a car are different from others'.
    In particular you seem feel that how the market values a car is
    irrelevant, hence odometer readings and salvage status are irrelevant.
    Fine for your and some people's needs. Not for mine and others',
    though. I want a car for which a price has been "set" by a resource
    like Kelly Blue Book. KBB.com will not spew out a price for cars with
    unknown mileage or having salvage status. Your argument is probably
    more with kbb than anything else.
     
    Elle, Sep 29, 2009
    #54
  15. Elle

    Elle Guest

    Jim, I think your goals for owning a car are different from others'.
    In particular you seem feel that how the market values a car is
    irrelevant, hence odometer readings and salvage status are irrelevant.
    Fine for your and some people's needs. Not for mine and others',
    though. I want a car for which a price has been "set" by a resource
    like Kelly Blue Book. KBB.com will not spew out a price for cars with
    unknown mileage or having salvage status. Your argument is probably
    more with kbb than anything else.
     
    Elle, Sep 29, 2009
    #55
  16. Elle

    jim beam Guest

    again, i think you're the victim of kbb's self-promotion propaganda.
    kbb is simply "reported" prices [dmv taxes anyone?], not actual market
    transactions.

    example: honda crx.
    here in the san francsico bay area, kbb has a 91 crx si is listed as
    $2130 for "excellent condition". what an utter crock! a real "street"
    price of that vehicle in good shape is $4k - $6k. i've seen people
    selling non-rolling crx shells here on craigslist for $1500. and i have
    personally witnessed people outside a seller's door waving $100 bills
    and bidding the price of for-sale crx's up to 2 or 3x asking.

    bottom line - consider whose interests kbb pricing may serve. and
    consider how they get their "data".
     
    jim beam, Sep 30, 2009
    #56
  17. Elle

    jim beam Guest

    again, i think you're the victim of kbb's self-promotion propaganda.
    kbb is simply "reported" prices [dmv taxes anyone?], not actual market
    transactions.

    example: honda crx.
    here in the san francsico bay area, kbb has a 91 crx si is listed as
    $2130 for "excellent condition". what an utter crock! a real "street"
    price of that vehicle in good shape is $4k - $6k. i've seen people
    selling non-rolling crx shells here on craigslist for $1500. and i have
    personally witnessed people outside a seller's door waving $100 bills
    and bidding the price of for-sale crx's up to 2 or 3x asking.

    bottom line - consider whose interests kbb pricing may serve. and
    consider how they get their "data".
     
    jim beam, Sep 30, 2009
    #57
  18. Elle

    Elle Guest

    First I'd have to consider how you get your data, the paucity of it,
    whether what you are talking about is ricers, etc. ;-)
     
    Elle, Sep 30, 2009
    #58
  19. Elle

    Elle Guest

    First I'd have to consider how you get your data, the paucity of it,
    whether what you are talking about is ricers, etc. ;-)
     
    Elle, Sep 30, 2009
    #59
  20. Elle

    jim beam Guest

    ricers aren't buyers/sellers?
     
    jim beam, Sep 30, 2009
    #60
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.