Comparison b/w Civic SI, Civic DX-G, Corolla, & Matrix?

Discussion in 'Civic' started by griffin, Jun 3, 2004.

  1. griffin

    JM Guest

    Corolla, definitely. I rented one of these for several days 2 years
    ago. Fast, roomy, comfortable, great gas mileage. The Civic is,
    unfortunately, just a "cheap secretary's car" as one car publication
    described it (no offense to secretaries, God bless them).

    But the Civic is just no where near the refinement standard set by the
    Accord.

    As a daily driver, I know that I could live with a Corolla. I
    wouldn't say that about a Civic despite my Honda brand loyalty.

    Unfortunately, my take is that Toyota dealers on average are ranked
    even lower than Honda dealers for satisfaction.

    JM.
     
    JM, Aug 23, 2004
    #81
  2. griffin

    JM Guest

    Corolla, definitely. I rented one of these for several days 2 years
    ago. Fast, roomy, comfortable, great gas mileage. The Civic is,
    unfortunately, just a "cheap secretary's car" as one car publication
    described it (no offense to secretaries, God bless them).

    But the Civic is just no where near the refinement standard set by the
    Accord.

    As a daily driver, I know that I could live with a Corolla. I
    wouldn't say that about a Civic despite my Honda brand loyalty.

    Unfortunately, my take is that Toyota dealers on average are ranked
    even lower than Honda dealers for satisfaction.

    JM.
     
    JM, Aug 23, 2004
    #82
  3. griffin

    griffin Guest

    Ya, I actually am going to be shopping from now until February for one. Of
    the four Toyota dealerships here, one of them is so shifty I wouldn't even
    consider letting them look at a tricycle because they'd probably tell me it
    needed $2000 in repairs. There's one here that doesn't seem too bad;
    however, I'm going to take the next six months to try and locate one
    privately so as to avoid being raped.

    As for repair shops ...I just hope anything that wants to break does so
    before warranty expiration ...otherwise I just have to hope that it
    maintains it's Corolla-Reliability factor. I'm scared to take them to any
    joeblow repair shop and even more scared to take it to the Toyota repair
    shop - not because of the lack of quality repairs but because I don't have
    time for a second job to pay for them.

    griffin
    '97 Corolla SD
    '85 Jeep CJ7
     
    griffin, Aug 23, 2004
    #83
  4. griffin

    griffin Guest

    Ya, I actually am going to be shopping from now until February for one. Of
    the four Toyota dealerships here, one of them is so shifty I wouldn't even
    consider letting them look at a tricycle because they'd probably tell me it
    needed $2000 in repairs. There's one here that doesn't seem too bad;
    however, I'm going to take the next six months to try and locate one
    privately so as to avoid being raped.

    As for repair shops ...I just hope anything that wants to break does so
    before warranty expiration ...otherwise I just have to hope that it
    maintains it's Corolla-Reliability factor. I'm scared to take them to any
    joeblow repair shop and even more scared to take it to the Toyota repair
    shop - not because of the lack of quality repairs but because I don't have
    time for a second job to pay for them.

    griffin
    '97 Corolla SD
    '85 Jeep CJ7
     
    griffin, Aug 23, 2004
    #84
  5. griffin

    griffin Guest

    Ya, I actually am going to be shopping from now until February for one. Of
    the four Toyota dealerships here, one of them is so shifty I wouldn't even
    consider letting them look at a tricycle because they'd probably tell me it
    needed $2000 in repairs. There's one here that doesn't seem too bad;
    however, I'm going to take the next six months to try and locate one
    privately so as to avoid being raped.

    As for repair shops ...I just hope anything that wants to break does so
    before warranty expiration ...otherwise I just have to hope that it
    maintains it's Corolla-Reliability factor. I'm scared to take them to any
    joeblow repair shop and even more scared to take it to the Toyota repair
    shop - not because of the lack of quality repairs but because I don't have
    time for a second job to pay for them.

    griffin
    '97 Corolla SD
    '85 Jeep CJ7
     
    griffin, Aug 23, 2004
    #85
  6. Okay - you have kid(s? in a few years?)
    The best option is a Matrix. You get a Corolla drivetrain with
    a mini-suv body on it. Bang-for-the buck, it's the best option
    out there*
    Ah. This may change things a bit. 10-15 year reliability is - well,
    that requires a different type of car like a Camry or Avalon or LeSabre
    or Accord V6 or... Econoboxes aren't designed to last much more than
    10 years before they become regular residents at the local repair shop.

    If you want a family car that will last 15 years, get a stock LeSabre.
    It has all of the features stock as a loaded Corolla, plus ABS and
    pther goodies. With rebates, it's just about $21-$22K and is
    actually a decent car. A stock Crown Vic would be my second choice
    as you can also get one for $20K after rebates and they are massively
    overbuilt for fleet use. For personal transportation, they work
    very well. Just don't get a used one - they are 90%+ abused fleet
    vehicles.

    The Avalon is also a superb car that's very VERY simmilar to
    the LeSabre, but Toyota isn't offering the deals like GM is,
    so it drops to third place. $5K is a big deal. Still a
    MUCH MUCH MUCH better car than a Corolla or Matrix can ever hope
    to be.

    Or, just get a car for 5-8 years or so. That's a nice econobox.
    Then I have a solution for you.

    The same exact car is sold under the GM badge. Same assembly line,
    same engine. Bit different interior features(minor) - but - GM's
    amazing financing and rebates. This drops the price of the car
    down to just over what an *ECHO* costs. The Pontical Vibe is
    the best deal out there right now. Toyota quality, GM pricing. :)

    But - again, it's not a true 15 year solution. You need a bigger,
    tougher built car for that.
     
    Joseph Oberlander, Aug 23, 2004
    #86
  7. Okay - you have kid(s? in a few years?)
    The best option is a Matrix. You get a Corolla drivetrain with
    a mini-suv body on it. Bang-for-the buck, it's the best option
    out there*
    Ah. This may change things a bit. 10-15 year reliability is - well,
    that requires a different type of car like a Camry or Avalon or LeSabre
    or Accord V6 or... Econoboxes aren't designed to last much more than
    10 years before they become regular residents at the local repair shop.

    If you want a family car that will last 15 years, get a stock LeSabre.
    It has all of the features stock as a loaded Corolla, plus ABS and
    pther goodies. With rebates, it's just about $21-$22K and is
    actually a decent car. A stock Crown Vic would be my second choice
    as you can also get one for $20K after rebates and they are massively
    overbuilt for fleet use. For personal transportation, they work
    very well. Just don't get a used one - they are 90%+ abused fleet
    vehicles.

    The Avalon is also a superb car that's very VERY simmilar to
    the LeSabre, but Toyota isn't offering the deals like GM is,
    so it drops to third place. $5K is a big deal. Still a
    MUCH MUCH MUCH better car than a Corolla or Matrix can ever hope
    to be.

    Or, just get a car for 5-8 years or so. That's a nice econobox.
    Then I have a solution for you.

    The same exact car is sold under the GM badge. Same assembly line,
    same engine. Bit different interior features(minor) - but - GM's
    amazing financing and rebates. This drops the price of the car
    down to just over what an *ECHO* costs. The Pontical Vibe is
    the best deal out there right now. Toyota quality, GM pricing. :)

    But - again, it's not a true 15 year solution. You need a bigger,
    tougher built car for that.
     
    Joseph Oberlander, Aug 23, 2004
    #87
  8. Okay - you have kid(s? in a few years?)
    The best option is a Matrix. You get a Corolla drivetrain with
    a mini-suv body on it. Bang-for-the buck, it's the best option
    out there*
    Ah. This may change things a bit. 10-15 year reliability is - well,
    that requires a different type of car like a Camry or Avalon or LeSabre
    or Accord V6 or... Econoboxes aren't designed to last much more than
    10 years before they become regular residents at the local repair shop.

    If you want a family car that will last 15 years, get a stock LeSabre.
    It has all of the features stock as a loaded Corolla, plus ABS and
    pther goodies. With rebates, it's just about $21-$22K and is
    actually a decent car. A stock Crown Vic would be my second choice
    as you can also get one for $20K after rebates and they are massively
    overbuilt for fleet use. For personal transportation, they work
    very well. Just don't get a used one - they are 90%+ abused fleet
    vehicles.

    The Avalon is also a superb car that's very VERY simmilar to
    the LeSabre, but Toyota isn't offering the deals like GM is,
    so it drops to third place. $5K is a big deal. Still a
    MUCH MUCH MUCH better car than a Corolla or Matrix can ever hope
    to be.

    Or, just get a car for 5-8 years or so. That's a nice econobox.
    Then I have a solution for you.

    The same exact car is sold under the GM badge. Same assembly line,
    same engine. Bit different interior features(minor) - but - GM's
    amazing financing and rebates. This drops the price of the car
    down to just over what an *ECHO* costs. The Pontical Vibe is
    the best deal out there right now. Toyota quality, GM pricing. :)

    But - again, it's not a true 15 year solution. You need a bigger,
    tougher built car for that.
     
    Joseph Oberlander, Aug 23, 2004
    #88
  9. No. Chrysler also didn't fix their transmissions.
    You'd have to be a class-A fool to but anything from them
    other than a Viper or Wrangler - the only two good vehicles
    they make.
     
    Joseph Oberlander, Aug 23, 2004
    #89
  10. No. Chrysler also didn't fix their transmissions.
    You'd have to be a class-A fool to but anything from them
    other than a Viper or Wrangler - the only two good vehicles
    they make.
     
    Joseph Oberlander, Aug 23, 2004
    #90
  11. No. Chrysler also didn't fix their transmissions.
    You'd have to be a class-A fool to but anything from them
    other than a Viper or Wrangler - the only two good vehicles
    they make.
     
    Joseph Oberlander, Aug 23, 2004
    #91
  12. 2004 Vibe(base model, automatic): $13.5K after rebates. The trick
    then is to toss in the supercharger and turn it into an automatic
    version of the GT - faster than the GT and less $$ on insurance.

    Or just get one for $13.5K(13K with manual) - there's just no
    better econobox deal out there right now.

    Or...
    2004 LeSabre Custom. No options - just a stock model.
    ABS, A/C, automatic, and so on - all standard. I added only the
    Touring Suspension, which is important. Comes with a CD radio
    already. It has traction control, a computer with a HUD
    (displays mph on the windshield) as well. Trip mileage,
    diagnostics, mpg, and so on - it's a SLICK computer system
    that you don't usually find on anything other than cars like
    Volvos and Lexus.

    Oh - it also gets 27mpg highway. 3500lbs, 210HP, and still
    gets small car highway mileage.

    LIST BASE TMV
    Total with Options and Delivery $27,050 $24,796 $25,091
    Incentives & Rebates -$5,000
    Customer Cash Adjusted True Market Value $20,091

    That's suddenly worth considering. $20K for a car that's
    comparable to an Avalon and twice what a typical econobox
    is? $5K in rebates is a lot of repairs and gas.

    *note* - you know, I don't really like GM products much - I'm
    more of an IS300 Sportcross fan myself. But - my old LeSabre
    still runs. At 18 years old and 150K it still won't come
    close to actually dying. As much as I didn't want to admit
    it - the thing is actually a very reliable car. Lol. Only
    my old Volvo 240 actually cost me less to maintain.

    The new ones are very reliable as well - the engine is bulletproof.
    Probably one of the best engines ever made, in fact. Maintainence
    is actually LESS expensive than on a Camry or Accord V6 last I
    checked. Superb family car - really the only large car that
    GM makes that is a good choice. Way better than a Saturn.
     
    Joseph Oberlander, Aug 23, 2004
    #92
  13. 2004 Vibe(base model, automatic): $13.5K after rebates. The trick
    then is to toss in the supercharger and turn it into an automatic
    version of the GT - faster than the GT and less $$ on insurance.

    Or just get one for $13.5K(13K with manual) - there's just no
    better econobox deal out there right now.

    Or...
    2004 LeSabre Custom. No options - just a stock model.
    ABS, A/C, automatic, and so on - all standard. I added only the
    Touring Suspension, which is important. Comes with a CD radio
    already. It has traction control, a computer with a HUD
    (displays mph on the windshield) as well. Trip mileage,
    diagnostics, mpg, and so on - it's a SLICK computer system
    that you don't usually find on anything other than cars like
    Volvos and Lexus.

    Oh - it also gets 27mpg highway. 3500lbs, 210HP, and still
    gets small car highway mileage.

    LIST BASE TMV
    Total with Options and Delivery $27,050 $24,796 $25,091
    Incentives & Rebates -$5,000
    Customer Cash Adjusted True Market Value $20,091

    That's suddenly worth considering. $20K for a car that's
    comparable to an Avalon and twice what a typical econobox
    is? $5K in rebates is a lot of repairs and gas.

    *note* - you know, I don't really like GM products much - I'm
    more of an IS300 Sportcross fan myself. But - my old LeSabre
    still runs. At 18 years old and 150K it still won't come
    close to actually dying. As much as I didn't want to admit
    it - the thing is actually a very reliable car. Lol. Only
    my old Volvo 240 actually cost me less to maintain.

    The new ones are very reliable as well - the engine is bulletproof.
    Probably one of the best engines ever made, in fact. Maintainence
    is actually LESS expensive than on a Camry or Accord V6 last I
    checked. Superb family car - really the only large car that
    GM makes that is a good choice. Way better than a Saturn.
     
    Joseph Oberlander, Aug 23, 2004
    #93
  14. 2004 Vibe(base model, automatic): $13.5K after rebates. The trick
    then is to toss in the supercharger and turn it into an automatic
    version of the GT - faster than the GT and less $$ on insurance.

    Or just get one for $13.5K(13K with manual) - there's just no
    better econobox deal out there right now.

    Or...
    2004 LeSabre Custom. No options - just a stock model.
    ABS, A/C, automatic, and so on - all standard. I added only the
    Touring Suspension, which is important. Comes with a CD radio
    already. It has traction control, a computer with a HUD
    (displays mph on the windshield) as well. Trip mileage,
    diagnostics, mpg, and so on - it's a SLICK computer system
    that you don't usually find on anything other than cars like
    Volvos and Lexus.

    Oh - it also gets 27mpg highway. 3500lbs, 210HP, and still
    gets small car highway mileage.

    LIST BASE TMV
    Total with Options and Delivery $27,050 $24,796 $25,091
    Incentives & Rebates -$5,000
    Customer Cash Adjusted True Market Value $20,091

    That's suddenly worth considering. $20K for a car that's
    comparable to an Avalon and twice what a typical econobox
    is? $5K in rebates is a lot of repairs and gas.

    *note* - you know, I don't really like GM products much - I'm
    more of an IS300 Sportcross fan myself. But - my old LeSabre
    still runs. At 18 years old and 150K it still won't come
    close to actually dying. As much as I didn't want to admit
    it - the thing is actually a very reliable car. Lol. Only
    my old Volvo 240 actually cost me less to maintain.

    The new ones are very reliable as well - the engine is bulletproof.
    Probably one of the best engines ever made, in fact. Maintainence
    is actually LESS expensive than on a Camry or Accord V6 last I
    checked. Superb family car - really the only large car that
    GM makes that is a good choice. Way better than a Saturn.
     
    Joseph Oberlander, Aug 23, 2004
    #94
  15. griffin

    Ghislain Guest

    You are using US instead of Canadian prices. A LeSabre Custom is $34K in
    Canada. Even with rebates it will definitely cost more than $20K. However
    you can get a base Vibe for approximately $20K plus GST and PST.
     
    Ghislain, Aug 23, 2004
    #95
  16. griffin

    Ghislain Guest

    You are using US instead of Canadian prices. A LeSabre Custom is $34K in
    Canada. Even with rebates it will definitely cost more than $20K. However
    you can get a base Vibe for approximately $20K plus GST and PST.
     
    Ghislain, Aug 23, 2004
    #96
  17. griffin

    Ghislain Guest

    You are using US instead of Canadian prices. A LeSabre Custom is $34K in
    Canada. Even with rebates it will definitely cost more than $20K. However
    you can get a base Vibe for approximately $20K plus GST and PST.
     
    Ghislain, Aug 23, 2004
    #97
  18. griffin

    griffin Guest

    Or I can just get a B-pack Corolla Sport that has all of the bells and
    whistles. I wouldn't want a HUD anyway ...too complicated and if it ever
    broke it'd bankrupt me getting it fixed.

    And yea ...convert that to CDN $ and the prices are much different.
     
    griffin, Aug 23, 2004
    #98
  19. griffin

    griffin Guest

    Or I can just get a B-pack Corolla Sport that has all of the bells and
    whistles. I wouldn't want a HUD anyway ...too complicated and if it ever
    broke it'd bankrupt me getting it fixed.

    And yea ...convert that to CDN $ and the prices are much different.
     
    griffin, Aug 23, 2004
    #99
  20. griffin

    griffin Guest

    Or I can just get a B-pack Corolla Sport that has all of the bells and
    whistles. I wouldn't want a HUD anyway ...too complicated and if it ever
    broke it'd bankrupt me getting it fixed.

    And yea ...convert that to CDN $ and the prices are much different.
     
    griffin, Aug 23, 2004
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.