Corolla, definitely. I rented one of these for several days 2 years ago. Fast, roomy, comfortable, great gas mileage. The Civic is, unfortunately, just a "cheap secretary's car" as one car publication described it (no offense to secretaries, God bless them). But the Civic is just no where near the refinement standard set by the Accord. As a daily driver, I know that I could live with a Corolla. I wouldn't say that about a Civic despite my Honda brand loyalty. Unfortunately, my take is that Toyota dealers on average are ranked even lower than Honda dealers for satisfaction. JM.