FIRST oil change - 03 4 cyl Accord

Discussion in 'Accord' started by Jim, Aug 13, 2003.

  1. Jim

    Gus Guest

    Not in big city use (I'm thinking NYC here, maybe it's an extreme example).
     
    Gus, Aug 18, 2003
    #21
  2. example).

    I've read the test. The taxis were rarely shut off.
     
    Stephen Bigelow, Aug 18, 2003
    #22
  3. Jim

    Jim Guest

    Thanks to all that replied! I will take the middle ground and do the oil and
    filter between 5K and 7500. The first oil change I will do at 7500 per the
    dealer (It's free at that mileage) even though the book says 10K for this
    one due to break-in oil.
    A guy that writes an Auto Column in my local paper never lets a week go by
    that he doesn't harp that 3K oil changes are so important - more so in
    hotter running newer cars. He writes that his shop does 100 cars a week so
    he knows what he is talking about. Always brings up the Toyota fiasco of a
    few years back where they sludged up when changed at 7500 and no sludge when
    done at 3K. I won't read his column anymore....I thought he was on to
    something.
    Jim
     
    Jim, Aug 18, 2003
    #23
  4. If you really want to have data on your oil, and know when what intervals
    work for YOU. Have the oil analyzed. You will find a great deal about how
    your engine is wearing and how the oil is holding up.
    I recommend http://www.blackstone-labs.com/ they have done good work for
    me. It helps to have actual data to assist in making choices about car care.

    Regards,
    Mark
     
    Poots Brownhole, Aug 27, 2003
    #24
  5. Jim

    wdb Guest

    Oil changes depend on several things. The conditions where you drive (hot or
    cold, damp or dry) The type of driving you do (short trips, stop and go or long
    trips), the condition of the engine and the type of oil used. I have worked for
    a company for 25 years which has service vehicles who's maintenance frequency
    is determined by the assigned drivers. Although I do not see anymore engine
    failures in vehicles with 3K oil changes then with 7k+ oil changes up to about
    80K miles, the vehicles which have longer oil change intervals do not seem to
    have that original new car power the ones which get the 3K oil changes seem to
    have. Also, the ones which had long oil change intervals have more problems with
    throttle bodies clogging and egr failures. When you look in the oil filler hole
    in the valve cover, you can see sludge and heavy brown glaze on everything in
    the 7K+ oil change interval cars. The 3K change interval cars have nice clean
    camshafts and valve springs and do not have problems with the EGR or throttle
    body. The bottom line is that cars in our fleet which were not seeing 3K oil
    changes obviously had a bit more engine wear and although they still ran, they
    did not run as good. If you are going to trade the car before 100K, by all
    means, let it go to 7.5K and a filter every other oil change. But if you want
    this car to perform like new for over 100K, bite the bullit and change that oil
    at around 3 - 4K with a filter. My rule of thumb is that if I can not easily see
    the line on the dipstick through the oil, it is too dark and too contaminated
    with the byproducts of combustion and needs to be changed. Unless there is
    something wrong with the engine, this should happen around 4K miles. Oh, this is
    with good quality standard oils. Some synthetics will hold up a bit better.
     
    wdb, Sep 18, 2003
    #25

  6. I to own a 2003 Honda Accord EX-L I also had the problem of when to
    change the oil.
    I was always brought up to change oil @ 3000 miles. so to make a long
    story short I
    settled on 5000 mile oil change.it's easy to remember and it's half
    way between 3&7500
    I came to this conclusion after reading a post from another Google
    member about the same
    dilemma,He (the poster) was a mechanical engineer He had sent oil to
    the lad @3000&5000
    and saw no difference in breakdown. Color of oil does not matter. The
    next time you go to get
    oil look @ the oil itself you will see some oil's start out dark and
    some clear (I like the clear oil)
    so that shoots that theory of dark?
    oil change it! do what you feel comfortable with but in my opinion
    5,000 is just about right. just use a good brand of oil and oil
    filter.
     
    Todd Sanderhoff, Sep 19, 2003
    #26
  7. Jim

    TL Guest

    I missed the original postings, but I note in the subject that the
    original topic was FIRST oil change. My understanding is that you
    should wait the full period called for in the maintenance schedule as
    there is a special break-in oil in the car.

    After that, I think it is all a combination of speculation combined
    with hype from the oil change industry. Many years ago (and I realize
    that oil chemistry has evolved) an oil engineer told me that it is the
    filter, not the oil that is the critical change element. That's kind
    of backward to what I read in the Honda maintenance that suggests
    changing the filter only every other oil change. This engineer said
    that much of the varnish type deposits come from new oil in the first
    few thousand miles and that changing too frequently simply adds more
    deposits without any real benefit since the oil would be still just
    fine. Of course that's just one expert's opinion and some years back.

    I have heard numerous times that lab analysis of oil shows that it
    holds up very well over much longer periods than the 3K or even 5K
    intervals would suggest. Of course it certainly isn't in the interest
    of the oil companies or oil change industry to promote that. I've
    never heard any reason for the "standard" 3K interval other than heavy
    advertising / promotion by the industry that benefits most from short
    interval changes.
     
    TL, Sep 19, 2003
    #27
  8. Hmmm...100 oil changes a week for drivers who change at 3000 miles at
    $25 per oil change, minus $10 for all the supplies/hazmat handling/labor
    costs minus $5 for facility costs times 52 weeks a year means $52,000 to
    this guy's bottom line. (All numbers derived through rectal estimation,
    or "I pulled 'em out of my ass.")

    Now! If all his customers were changing oil every 6000 miles, he's only
    doing $26,000 profit in oil changes.

    Twenty-six grand may be chump change to a car dealer, but a little chump
    change here and a little there and pretty soon you're dealing in real
    money.

    Oh yeah...I'm Jim. Tomorrow I pick up my 86 Accord.

    --jmowreader
     
    Jim Mowreader, Sep 29, 2003
    #28
  9. Nope, the 3000-mile interval came around in 1979, and it was for smog
    control. I have no idea why, but cars with clean oil pollute less than
    cars with dirty oil. (All the guys I know in California tell me they
    always change the oil just before they're smogged, since their cars can
    pass the sniffer test easier with fresh oil than with used.)

    When the dealers were told "we're going to a 3000-mile change interval
    on the oil," the almost unanimous response was "this is gonna kill us,
    we can't hang with this." Fine, said Pennzoil, we'll take matters into
    our own hands...and they started a little chain of stores that did
    nothing but change oil really fast. You know them as "Jiffy Lube." (Now
    Pennzoil belongs to Shell and so does Jiffy Lube.)

    --jmowreader
     
    Jim Mowreader, Sep 29, 2003
    #29
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.