head gasket

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by jim beam, Jun 4, 2006.

  1. jim beam

    jim beam Guest

    spent all day yesterday swapping the head gasket on the civic. ugh.
    utterly non-trivial.

    it's been a while since i've done that job on any car and you forget...
    i have to say, the civic is a royal pita. it's not just the picky
    stuff like the hard-to-get-at hoses, the hidden mounting brackets, etc.,
    it's the clean-up. the gasket is well and truly welded to the head and
    the block, so clean-up takes ages. the problem is, because of the
    relatively soft alloy, you can't just use a chisel on the old gasket
    material, so i ended up having to shave it off. it took about 3.5 hours
    for that part alone, 7 hours total.

    in the end, both the head and the block were as clean and as non-damaged
    as i could make them, and so far, all appears well in terms of
    gas-tightness, but here's my thought for the group:

    it's impossible to make a "clean" job of this work. as you scrape, old
    head material gets into the cylinders, the water jacket, everywhere.
    and even with cleaning the engine well beforehand, grit still hides out
    and gets everywhere too. now, having cleaned up, test driven, changed
    the oil, etc., i look in the oil filler hole and sure enough, there's
    grit scratching on the cam lobes. i hate to imagine what the oil pump
    looks like. the only way you could ever do this work "successfully" is
    have access to semi-surgical cleaning facilities, and a whole bunch of time.

    i therefore don't expect this engine to last anywhere near as long as it
    otherwise would have - with such contamination, wear will be greatly
    accelerated. in the future, excessive though it may sound at first
    sight, i'll not bother changing gaskets on an older honda again - i'll
    just go straight to the low mileage jdm engine. it'll be quicker and at
    about $300 for my D15, it'll be a good deal more economic.
     
    jim beam, Jun 4, 2006
    #1
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.