Motortrend article: 100 MPG+ Chevy Volt, GM's "Moon Shot"

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by johngdole, Feb 5, 2009.

  1. johngdole

    Scott Dorsey Guest

    I've driven a couple dozen of them, since my employers are cheapskates
    and get me econoboxes to rent when I am on travel.
    Again, do a comparison. Drive an MR2 and then a Corvette. Neither one
    of them is a Lotus by any means, but the whole difference in design
    philosophy becomes very evident. Of course, the MR2 is gone now, but
    the philosophy isn't.

    Even if you compare mid-sized cars you'll find GM is still obsessed with
    having huge amounts of centering force as a substitute for actual steering
    control. The Corolla doesn't have big centering springs to hide the dead
    band because it has much less of a dead band to begin with.

    Now, as I said, it's getting better and the CTS is actually a radical
    departure from GM tradition in terms of suspension and steering feel.
    I'm hoping that starts to trickle down to the rest of the line.
    No, not at all. Toyota and Honda are in many ways following the same path
    that GM got themselves in trouble with. It's interesting, though, that
    Toyota and Honda started out with one product line and split them into two,
    whereas GM started out as multiple companies merging together into one.
    --scott
     
    Scott Dorsey, Feb 6, 2009
    #41
  2. I want a car without stupid shiney trim on the side windows because it
    causes glare when I north or south during the early morning or late
    afternoon, but if I buy a car, I'm forced to buy that stupid trim. I
    also want a car that never needs washing and that stays cool when it's
    parked in the sun with the windows rolled up, but I'm forced to buy
    cars without those features.
     
    larry moe 'n curly, Feb 6, 2009
    #42
  3. johngdole

    Mike Hunter Guest

    Speaking of the Toyota Venza, I looked at one at the Philadelphia auto show
    the other day. If the driver is long legged and has the seat back, the seat
    is around three inches from the rear seat. Even a child could not sit
    behind the driver. LOL
     
    Mike Hunter, Feb 6, 2009
    #43
  4. johngdole

    N8N Guest

    This is a joke, right? A Grand Ma, sporty?

    I'd rather have a car as small as possible that doesn't feel like a
    penalty box. Think VW Scirocco or Porsche 914, or for a higher end
    and more current example, Lotus Elise.
    Nope, nor do I care. I can't remember the last time I drove a GM car
    that didn't piss me off in some regard.

    (thinks)

    OK, I do recall. It was when I borrowed a Malibu while my Impala was
    in the shop. The 'bu was actually fairly decent, although bland as
    vanilla pudding.

    nate
     
    N8N, Feb 6, 2009
    #44
  5. johngdole

    Mike Hunter Guest

    Nope, nor do I care. I can't remember the last time I drove a GM car
    that didn't piss me off in some regard.

    (thinks)

    OK, I do recall. It was when I borrowed a Malibu while my Impala was
    in the shop. The 'bu was actually fairly decent, although bland as
    vanilla pudding.

    nate
     
    Mike Hunter, Feb 6, 2009
    #45
  6. johngdole

    80 Knight Guest

    **This is a joke, right? A Grand Ma, sporty?

    The Grand Am GT's are very sporty. Especially with the Ram Air hood. My
    sister has an '03, and the thing is rather quick too for a 3400.

    **Nope, nor do I care. I can't remember the last time I drove a GM car
    **that didn't piss me off in some regard.
    **(thinks)
    **OK, I do recall. It was when I borrowed a Malibu while my Impala was
    **in the shop. The 'bu was actually fairly decent, although bland as
    **vanilla pudding.

    And I think the same about Porsches'. It's called opinions. You like
    Porsche and Volkswagen's. Personally, I wouldn't own either if you paid me
    too. Not because they are not reliable, but because they are ugly.
    Different people have different opinions, views, and experiences.
    Unfortunately the Impala you drive happens to be a complete lemon. Most GM
    vehicles are not.
     
    80 Knight, Feb 6, 2009
    #46
  7. johngdole

    N8N Guest

    It could be fast (in a straight line) as a Corvette and it still
    wouldn't be sporty. A FWD midsize family car can't be made "sporty"
    by the addition of ugly plastic cladding and red backlighting for the
    gauges. A manual transmission option, decent sport seats, and a real
    handling suspension would be a good place to start.

    The fact that GM *thinks* that the Grand Am is sporty is also why
    people who want sporty cars don't think of GM as an option.
    It's not really a *lemon* per se, it's just an awful car. A complete
    ergonomic disaster, and loud as hell and slow to boot. It could get
    90 mpg and I'd still want to trade it in.

    nate
     
    N8N, Feb 6, 2009
    #47
  8. What's your point? People buy what they want, and no one forces them to buy
    anything. Unless you are saying you would purchase something just because
    the advertisement told you to, in which case, I would advise you to start
    using your brain, and to think for yourself.[/QUOTE]

    .....says the guy who, no doubt, has been convinced to buy something
    thanks to clever marketing.
     
    Elmo P. Shagnasty, Feb 6, 2009
    #48
  9. iPod.

    'Nuff said.
     
    Elmo P. Shagnasty, Feb 6, 2009
    #49
  10. johngdole

    80 Knight Guest

    9-16 year old's aren't usually purchasing new vehicles.
     
    80 Knight, Feb 6, 2009
    #50
  11. johngdole

    80 Knight Guest

    ....says the guy who, no doubt, has been convinced to buy something
    thanks to clever marketing.[/QUOTE]

    I'm definaltey not going to drop $50,000 just because the ad looked good.
     
    80 Knight, Feb 6, 2009
    #51
  12. johngdole

    Mike Hunter Guest

    Are you not the guy that said your "Shamwow" works great?

    ....says the guy who, no doubt, has been convinced to buy something
    thanks to clever marketing.[/QUOTE]
     
    Mike Hunter, Feb 6, 2009
    #52
  13. johngdole

    Mike Hunter Guest

    But, but, but do you not own a Toyota?


     
    Mike Hunter, Feb 6, 2009
    #53
  14. johngdole

    Mike Hunter Guest

    Apparently neither does our friend Elmo, he buys used cars
     
    Mike Hunter, Feb 6, 2009
    #54
  15. johngdole

    Ike Guest

    Interior dimensions are about the same as the highly successful Camry.

    And make no mistake - the Volt is *NOT* a "hybrid". The definition of
    the term was established by the founder of the genre - the Prius - in
    which the wheels can be driven by either an internal combustion engine
    or an electric motor.

    The Volt is a pure electric car, in which the engine-generator is an
    onboard battery charger that supplements charging via the grid.
     
    Ike, Feb 7, 2009
    #55
  16. johngdole

    Nate Nagel Guest

    It is a hybrid, albeit a different type. The Prius (and all other
    hybrids currently on the market) are "parallel hybrids" e.g. the engine
    and motor operate in parallel. The Volt is a "series hybrid" more akin
    to a diesel/electric locomotive than any automobile currently on the
    market. It may also be a "plug in hybrid," e.g. one that can run on
    electricity to the point of partial discharge and then be recharged from
    the grid rather than from its onboard ICE, depending on which rumors one
    listens to.

    Really, the Volt is an intriguing concept, but one has to wonder if a)
    battery technology really is good enough to make the "plug in"
    capability, if it is in fact so equipped when it comes to market, truly
    useful for more than a handful of ultra-short-trip commuters, and b) if
    it will suffer the fate of so many GM cars that appear promising on the
    show stand and somehow become homogenized, focus-grouped, and value
    engineered to the point of bland mediocrity by the time they hit the
    showroom (and to make matters worse - Fiero anyone - end up being not
    quite ready for prime time, and thus are discontinued due to poor
    reputation/sales just when they are finally starting to fulfill their
    initial promise)

    nate
     
    Nate Nagel, Feb 7, 2009
    #56
  17. johngdole

    Scott Dorsey Guest

    I think it will in many areas where electricity is cheap, because even
    if you're doing half your commute on the engine and half the commute on
    stored power, the savings can be considerable. However, there are places
    in this country where power is fourteen or fifteen cents per kilowatt hour
    and in these places, plug-in operation will be a net loss.

    One of the interesting things about the hybrids, though, is the possibility
    of adding a 60 Hz inverter and getting AC power out of the battery stack,
    for less money than running a field generator.
    My feeling is that this won't happen to the Volt because GM is pushing it
    through so fast that they won't have time to wreck it. Part of the problem
    with GM is that they try to make all their products everything to everyone,
    which makes them less desirable for anyone. I think they're trying to get
    the Volt out as quickly as possible, and the Volt is the vision of only a
    few people which makes it much less likely to be mangled this way. But I
    predict than unless something dramatic changes in GM management, they will
    wreck the design within five or six years by adding junk to it.
    --scott
     
    Scott Dorsey, Feb 7, 2009
    #57
  18. johngdole

    Hairy Guest

    I dare say that you are not "forced" to buy any car. When you buy a car,
    it's because you choose to buy a car. Besides, if you throw enough money at
    it, both of your concerns could be addressed.
     
    Hairy, Feb 7, 2009
    #58
  19. johngdole

    Hairy Guest

    The Chevy Blazer has been around for forty years. A bit long lived for a
    fad, don't ya think? And it certainly wasn't the first.
     
    Hairy, Feb 7, 2009
    #59
  20. johngdole

    Brent Guest

    The fiero was ready... it was exactly as the bean counters forced it to
    be. Once it proved to be a sales success then the engineers were allowed
    to do it properly instead of on the cheap. By then the name was ruined.
     
    Brent, Feb 7, 2009
    #60
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.