OT GM AND SYNTHETIC OIL

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by xxxxxxxx, Nov 24, 2003.

  1. xxxxxxxx

    Scott in Fla Guest

    No traffic jams cause all you guys are down here in Florida cloggin up
    MY roads <g>. eh?


    Scott in Florida
     
    Scott in Fla, Nov 26, 2003
    #41
  2. xxxxxxxx

    jjnunes Guest

    I suppose so it can meet a wide range of requirements. After all, like all
    products it is made to be SOLD.

    And many others. But there are countless examples where a thread goes on
    and on about to change the oil where it is unnecessary. They behave as if the
    reason the person had an analysis done was to give the regulars there
    something to say inane BS about. Get a life, I'd say.
     
    jjnunes, Nov 26, 2003
    #42
  3. xxxxxxxx

    Dan Gates Guest


    Scott (Dan puts on flame-proof underwear)

    The ones clogging up your roads are all of the old French. Look at your
    beaches -- full of fat old french guys in speedos and their blimp wives
    in bikinis!

    We in Ontario can't afford to take time off work to do that!

    Only in Quebec, (where, like most of the rest of Canada there is really
    on 10 weeks of good construction weather), would they have what is
    called "construction holiday" and stop all construction for 2 weeks in
    the middle of July!!

    Where do they get the time to actually get some work done???

    Dan
     
    Dan Gates, Nov 26, 2003
    #43
  4. xxxxxxxx

    Scott in Fla Guest

    French eh?

    Then they are open season???

    hmmmmmm...

    <lockin and loadin>


    Scott in Florida
     
    Scott in Fla, Nov 27, 2003
    #44
  5. xxxxxxxx

    Philip® Guest

    In
    Huw... over here... the 15w-50 and 0w-40 in Mobil1 are the only oils
    stating on the label they meet ACEA A3. But the local Benz dealer
    does use Valoline synthetic 5w-30. Funny... Valvoline "here" does
    not mention ACEA ratings.
     
    Philip®, Nov 27, 2003
    #45
  6. xxxxxxxx

    Philip® Guest

    In
    Turned into a confirmed bachelor / recluse, eh? Well, you ain't
    gonna get more living in a place where you'll literally freeze your
    nuts off! LOL
     
    Philip®, Nov 27, 2003
    #46
  7. xxxxxxxx

    jjnunes Guest

    Not true. Delvac 1 5W-40 is their most shear stable product. But it's CH4
    rated, so perhaps not always suitable for gasoline engines.
     
    jjnunes, Nov 27, 2003
    #47
  8. xxxxxxxx

    Philip® Guest

    In
    Wish I could find Delvac 1300 anywhere in southern CA .... short of
    meeting Guido in a dark corner of some truck stop. Comes in 15w-40
    and now 10w-30 too.

    http://www.mobil.com/USA-English/Lubes/PDS/NAUSE2CVLMOMobilDelvac1300
    Super.asp
     
    Philip®, Nov 27, 2003
    #48
  9. xxxxxxxx

    Dan Gates Guest

    Naw, I'm happily married, with two parasites. I was just emphasizing
    the point that I love it here and couldn't be lured to move.

    When observing those of the female persuasion and I'm informed of some
    factor that my limit my "chances" (ie, already married, plays for the
    other team, etc), I just say that that reduced my chances from very slim
    to absolutely zero. I have absolutely no desire to change my
    "situation". I just like to think I can.


    Dan
     
    Dan Gates, Nov 27, 2003
    #49
  10. That site is sort of interesting, although I don't take the comments
    Tell this to Mobil, who withdrew their AV-1 (aviation version of Mobil 1)
    from the market after they had to pay millions of dollars to repair and/or
    replace the Continental engines of all the aircraft owners who used AV-1.

    http://www.avweb.com/news/news/182892-1.html
     
    Scott MacLean, Nov 27, 2003
    #50
  11. Dan: I have never in my life inhaled air that cold, let alone
    Ah, you haven't lived until you're outside in -40 weather, take a good deep
    breath and feel the insides of your nose freeze. :)
     
    Scott MacLean, Nov 27, 2003
    #51
  12. xxxxxxxx

    jjnunes Guest

    What I am talking about is when the VIRGIN oil has say, 5 ppm of iron and
    somebody posts an analysis that has 2 ppm with said oil and then later posts
    an analysisthat shows 4 ppm for the same miles on the oil and everybody starts
    posting about how terrible the second analysis is and that something is wrong.

    You don't think that's stupid?
     
    jjnunes, Nov 27, 2003
    #52
  13. xxxxxxxx

    Mark A Guest

    That site is sort of interesting, although I don't take the comments
    Here is waht AVWeb magaizine says:

    "[AVWeb] started advising against the use of AV-1 in low-utilization
    owner-flown airplanes as early as 1991. Our rationale was that 100%
    synthetic oil is a superb lubricant but a lousy cleanser, and that cleansing
    is extremely important in piston aircraft engines because of their loose
    tolerances and the significant blow-by that can leak past the rings and
    contaminate the oil."

    "It's important to understand the mechanism at work here. Synthetic oil like
    AV-1 is composed of long, smooth polymer molecules that don't have all the
    little side branches that petroleum polymers do. This makes them extremely
    slippery and gives them excellent lubricating properties. Synthetic oils
    also lack the "light ends" of petroleum oils that can break down under
    extreme heat and create varnish and carbon deposits.

    But it's those same smooth, ultra-slippery molecules that give synthetic oil
    its Achilles' heel: the inability to hold lead salts and other contaminants
    in suspension. The synthetic oil molecules are simply too damned slippery to
    hang onto such contaminants, so they settle out of solution and form sludge
    deposits, particularly in areas of oil stagnation such as prop hubs, oil
    pans, and the inside of pistons.

    Tetraethyl lead is an octane enhancer used in avgas [not allowed in
    automible gasoline]. It doesn't belong in the oil. Two compression rings on
    each piston seal the combustion chamber and keep combustion confined to
    where they belong. As long as the rings do their job well, the lead will go
    out the exhaust pipe and the oil will stay relatively lead-free."

    "We believe that AV-1 engines that exhibit good compression test results are
    probably not at much risk of sludge formation and sludge-induced lubrication
    problems. Engines that exhibit early deterioration of compression are at
    greatest risk.

    Turbocharged engines appear to be much more likely to be contaminated
    because their higher combustion chamber pressures make blow-by more of a
    problem. The Gross and Eriksson engines were both turbo'd, and every owner
    we talked to in researching this article turned out to have a turbocharged
    engine. Ironically, AV-1 was especially popular among owners of turbos
    because of its resistance to coking under high heat."
     
    Mark A, Nov 27, 2003
    #53
  14. xxxxxxxx

    Philip® Guest

    In
    I"m not about to deliberately test my mortality in that manner!
    When it's 40 above zero, I'm bundled up and most likely indoors.
    Aside from being a southern California native, look up Raynauds
    syndrome.
     
    Philip®, Nov 28, 2003
    #54
  15. xxxxxxxx

    Philip® Guest

    In
    Let AVWeb explain to me WHY ..... Mobil1 did the best job of keeping
    my engine innards sparkling clean for 285,000 miles ... much cleaner
    than any dino oil used in previous engines. Is AVWeb implying "100%
    synthetic oil" is not the same "synthetic" (Mobil1) I put in my car
    because my car engine was so clean?
     
    Philip®, Nov 28, 2003
    #55
  16. xxxxxxxx

    Dan Gates Guest


    You guys think it's taxes that keep us poor up here! The problem is
    clothes! We have to be prepared for -40 C and plus 30 C!

    You guys are wussies!!! |>))

    Getting waaaaayyyyy OT now, I was on a plane back from Brazil with an
    octogenarian British X-Pat lady. She and her husband had left Britain
    after the war and set up an aerial survey firm in Brazil. Her big
    obsession, all the way from Rio to Newark (talk about a come-down), was
    "With similar histories, how come Canada does so well and Brazil does so
    poorly?"


    I replied that I thought it was the climate! If you landed at Montreal
    in May, with nothing but the clothes on you back, you better quickly
    figure out how to clear some land, plant a crop, build a shelter and
    store you food before winter comes, because if you didn't, you didn't
    have to worry about next year. In Brazil, if you didn't get any work
    done today, a mango would fall from the tree to feed you. If it rains
    today, it will dry out tomorrow. etc. There was no real incentive to
    establish a work ethic in Brazil, like there was here in Canada. Brazil
    was also conquered by "southern peoples" (Portugal) and Canada was
    conquered by "northern peoples" (Britain), again with a more difficult
    climate to deal with, and a stronger "incentive" to get things done.
    Now, with all of the stuff that makes our life easy, a lot of the work
    ethic has disappeared over the last couple of generations! But it still
    lies under the surface if you scratch hard enough.



    Dan
     
    Dan Gates, Nov 28, 2003
    #56
  17. xxxxxxxx

    Scott in Fla Guest

    ....very interesting, Dan.

    I'll have to contemplate your statements for awhile <g>.

    That could answer the differences in the States...too.

    Minnesota and Alabama.....hummmm

    Florida does not count...cause we got all the damned yankees that came
    down to mess up paradise <g>.



    Scott in Florida
     
    Scott in Fla, Nov 28, 2003
    #57
  18. xxxxxxxx

    Philip® Guest

    In
    Good observations. Do you wonder if predominantly cold climates also
    incline people favor collectivist economies?
     
    Philip®, Nov 29, 2003
    #58
  19. xxxxxxxx

    Phil Smith Guest

    Not like you think. Due to the isolated situation in which French
    culture developed in North America, they are about as French as a
    New Jerseyite speaking Elizabethan English. (Not the current Elizabeth,
    either!)
    You have to go backward about 350 years to make the connection.
    Be careful. Python-like, they CAN fart in your general direction!
    -psmith (Hi was not know how you could told Hi was Franch, dere, me. My
    spoke, she was too good; hit must have been my hacksident!)
     
    Phil Smith, Nov 29, 2003
    #59
  20. xxxxxxxx

    Huw Guest

    I meant the 0w/40. Sorry.

    I deal with it daily. The 0w/40 is a superior oil which stays in grade
    and lasts for longer drain intervals as proven by the Standards it
    meets and exceeds.

    It is such a pity then that it cannot meet any of the higher standards
    set for measuring this. In fact it is quite shear stable, there is no
    denying it. The 0w/40 is however proven to be stable and has other
    properties which allow it to be used for much extended drain intervals
    which are not possible with the present chemistry of most other
    viscosity grades of Mobil I.
    The Standards are just that.. "Standards" which allow a comparison of
    oils. Get over it and educate yourself.

    Huw
     
    Huw, Nov 29, 2003
    #60
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.