Questions about new Accord

Discussion in 'Accord' started by rev_otis_mcnatt, Oct 15, 2008.

  1. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Pszemol Guest

    So how are you going to prove that you have changed the oil?
    Traditional way was to show a copy of the invoice from the shop...
    In case of DIY, how do you do it?

    I change my oil or ATF and properly recycle it bringing used oil
    to local PepBoys shop but I wonder what troubles I am facing
    in case I will have contested warranty claim and warrantor
    wants to see all the proof of maintenance done on this car...
    Yes, I have purchased maintenance fluids, filters and kept
    the receipts, but from the legal point of view they proof only
    the fact I purchased these items. Statement can be made
    that I have actually never gone about doing these things and
    oil filter is still sitting on my garrage shelf :)
    I have 2004 without this feature and probably there is not many
    other group members with 2009 AND knowing how it works...

    I fully understant your question and I am also quite surprised
    with Elmo's answer :) I alsodo not know how really does it work,
    we can only guess. As a computer engineer I can infer that if
    the whole "user interface" consists of holding the single button
    to reset the indicator IT MUST be done the way you reset
    each thing separatelly. Each managed item like the oil life, air
    filter, ATF would have its own maintenance period requirement
    and clearing the warning would affect only this particular item.
    As you probably agree it would be silly if changing the engine
    oil every 5-8k miles and reseting the minder would also clear
    the "timer" for the ATF or air filter.

    In case you do some service which is not reported yet, so
    lets say you replace air filter before the air filter icon pops up
    on the screen, you as a user will not have the proper "user
    interface" to clear the minder. I am guessing clearing such
    thing before the indicator is there on the screen can be done
    only accessing the computer through the OBD-II connector
    if possible at all.

    There is also another thing to think about... The state of the oil
    is not directly measured with any sensor - it is "calculated"
    using some routine based on the car usage... The same is
    probably done for ATF or air filter.
     
    Pszemol, Oct 15, 2008
    #21
  2. I plan to buy the oil filters from the dealership (while under
    warranty),
    and of course keep the receipts for the oil, which also of course
    will
    be the recommended weight and quality--I plan to use Castrol
    5w-20 dino. I will also write all the particulars down in my
    little servcie book that came with the car, including the
    Oil Life reading when the oil was changed.
    I guess that's true, strictly speaking, but with all of the
    documentation you have, I think it would be a stretch
    for Honda to wiggle out of warranty work. It just wouldn't
    make any sense that detailed oriented owner like you
    would buy these items and not use them on his late
    model car. They could also look at the various installed
    components, including the condition of your motor oil in the engine.
    Yep, you're right. The manual doesn't address this. They make
    it sound like the whole system is reset when the oil is changed.
    Does your '04 just have a Minder for oil changes and not the
    other stuff?
    Yep, this is the way it was with BMW. When I first bought
    a car with this, I was, like you, thinking sensor. But it is simply
    based on a little formula that has as variables RPM, mileage,
    engine temp, etc. I could give you the actual formula BMW
    uses if you're interested. I always felt it was a bit inaccurate
    and pretentious since, in my view, if left out the most important
    thing: engine run time.

    Thanks for the intelligent response!
     
    rev_otis_mcnatt, Oct 15, 2008
    #22
  3. I plan to buy the oil filters from the dealership (while under
    warranty),
    and of course keep the receipts for the oil, which also of course
    will
    be the recommended weight and quality--I plan to use Castrol
    5w-20 dino. I will also write all the particulars down in my
    little servcie book that came with the car, including the
    Oil Life reading when the oil was changed.
    I guess that's true, strictly speaking, but with all of the
    documentation you have, I think it would be a stretch
    for Honda to wiggle out of warranty work. It just wouldn't
    make any sense that detailed oriented owner like you
    would buy these items and not use them on his late
    model car. They could also look at the various installed
    components, including the condition of your motor oil in the engine.
    Yep, you're right. The manual doesn't address this. They make
    it sound like the whole system is reset when the oil is changed.
    Does your '04 just have a Minder for oil changes and not the
    other stuff?
    Yep, this is the way it was with BMW. When I first bought
    a car with this, I was, like you, thinking sensor. But it is simply
    based on a little formula that has as variables RPM, mileage,
    engine temp, etc. I could give you the actual formula BMW
    uses if you're interested. I always felt it was a bit inaccurate
    and pretentious since, in my view, if left out the most important
    thing: engine run time.

    Thanks for the intelligent response!
     
    rev_otis_mcnatt, Oct 15, 2008
    #23
  4. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Truckdude Guest

    During the years I owned those cars, I did a great deal of "research"
    on the very common subject of argument with "car people": oil
    changes..
    best types/brands and frequency of change. As I've said, changing
    out factory oil in a new engine is not a bad idea at 5k miles. I also
    don't want to give the dealership ANY reason to try to weasel in the
    event of future warranty work, which they are known for.
    I care very much about conservation and environment, but it amazes me
    that no one here has understood my actual question about resetting.
    Honda owners? I think I'll try some of the forums and hope for
    at least higher I.Q's.

    =============================================

    I have an '07 Accord and an '08 Fit.

    On both cars the MM coordinates the other maintenance items in conjunction
    with oil changes. Yes, resetting the MM resets everything, but nothing
    shows up independently of the oil changes, so that is OK.

    Just a hint. You will get more information if you don't come across as such
    an asshole.

    ..
     
    Truckdude, Oct 15, 2008
    #24
  5. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Truckdude Guest

    During the years I owned those cars, I did a great deal of "research"
    on the very common subject of argument with "car people": oil
    changes..
    best types/brands and frequency of change. As I've said, changing
    out factory oil in a new engine is not a bad idea at 5k miles. I also
    don't want to give the dealership ANY reason to try to weasel in the
    event of future warranty work, which they are known for.
    I care very much about conservation and environment, but it amazes me
    that no one here has understood my actual question about resetting.
    Honda owners? I think I'll try some of the forums and hope for
    at least higher I.Q's.

    =============================================

    I have an '07 Accord and an '08 Fit.

    On both cars the MM coordinates the other maintenance items in conjunction
    with oil changes. Yes, resetting the MM resets everything, but nothing
    shows up independently of the oil changes, so that is OK.

    Just a hint. You will get more information if you don't come across as such
    an asshole.

    ..
     
    Truckdude, Oct 15, 2008
    #25
  6. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Pszemol Guest

    I can understant his frustration after reading Elmo's response...

    Response indicating not understanding the question after 2nd attempt.

    Looking at the message writing times I can only say Elmo did not
    have enough time for sleep and recharge his brain batteries... ;-)
     
    Pszemol, Oct 15, 2008
    #26
  7. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Pszemol Guest

    I can understant his frustration after reading Elmo's response...

    Response indicating not understanding the question after 2nd attempt.

    Looking at the message writing times I can only say Elmo did not
    have enough time for sleep and recharge his brain batteries... ;-)
     
    Pszemol, Oct 15, 2008
    #27
  8. Here is what happens with my 2006 Honda. Every now and then, the
    Maintenance Minder comes on and tells me what needs to be done. The
    oil change interval is averaging about 7000 miles or so. Other
    reminders come on at the same time as the oil change reminder, using
    codes. I look these codes up in the manual and I do those things too
    (cabin filter, air cleaner filter, etc.). When I reset the MM,
    everything goes away.

    The reminder intervals are based on driving habits and conditions.

    If you ever get a reminder to change the oil and nothing else, then I
    suspect you can reset just that reminder. But what ever shows up is
    all cleared by the same procedure as you describe: "holding down the
    button for 15 seconds"



    Elliot Richmond
    Itinerant astronomy teacher
     
    Elliot Richmond, Oct 15, 2008
    #28
  9. Here is what happens with my 2006 Honda. Every now and then, the
    Maintenance Minder comes on and tells me what needs to be done. The
    oil change interval is averaging about 7000 miles or so. Other
    reminders come on at the same time as the oil change reminder, using
    codes. I look these codes up in the manual and I do those things too
    (cabin filter, air cleaner filter, etc.). When I reset the MM,
    everything goes away.

    The reminder intervals are based on driving habits and conditions.

    If you ever get a reminder to change the oil and nothing else, then I
    suspect you can reset just that reminder. But what ever shows up is
    all cleared by the same procedure as you describe: "holding down the
    button for 15 seconds"



    Elliot Richmond
    Itinerant astronomy teacher
     
    Elliot Richmond, Oct 15, 2008
    #29
  10. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Dillon Pyron Guest

    Thus spake :
    No. You'll get a notice that says you need, for istance (looking at
    my 08 Fit this morning) A1 service. Looking in the book, this is oil
    and rotate. Both of those can and will be done at home this weekend.
    But eventually other items will need to be done and these will pop up
    on their own, at their own schedule. But if you replace the air
    filter when its service interval comes along and don't do the oil,
    which should also be done at the same time, the oil interval will be
    reset.

    Perhaps you should read the manual. It's all called out in nice
    detail.
     
    Dillon Pyron, Oct 16, 2008
    #30
  11. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Dillon Pyron Guest

    Thus spake :
    No. You'll get a notice that says you need, for istance (looking at
    my 08 Fit this morning) A1 service. Looking in the book, this is oil
    and rotate. Both of those can and will be done at home this weekend.
    But eventually other items will need to be done and these will pop up
    on their own, at their own schedule. But if you replace the air
    filter when its service interval comes along and don't do the oil,
    which should also be done at the same time, the oil interval will be
    reset.

    Perhaps you should read the manual. It's all called out in nice
    detail.
     
    Dillon Pyron, Oct 16, 2008
    #31
  12. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Dillon Pyron Guest

    Thus spake :
    Ummm, Honda says NO. Change when called for. Back in "the good old
    days" (when I drove a Ford with a Boss 351) changing the oil at 1000
    miles post purchase was standard. But there aren't any "break in
    oils" anymore.

    What kind of oil do you plan to use? For years, I used GTX 20W-50 due
    to the environment I was driving my Hondas in. Then a Honda mechanic
    told me that they recommended 5W-30 and it turned out to be cheaper.
     
    Dillon Pyron, Oct 16, 2008
    #32
  13. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Dillon Pyron Guest

    Thus spake :
    Ummm, Honda says NO. Change when called for. Back in "the good old
    days" (when I drove a Ford with a Boss 351) changing the oil at 1000
    miles post purchase was standard. But there aren't any "break in
    oils" anymore.

    What kind of oil do you plan to use? For years, I used GTX 20W-50 due
    to the environment I was driving my Hondas in. Then a Honda mechanic
    told me that they recommended 5W-30 and it turned out to be cheaper.
     
    Dillon Pyron, Oct 16, 2008
    #33
  14. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Dillon Pyron Guest

    Actually, by Federal law, they have to show that you voided the
    warranty by not performing the maintenance. You don't have to prove
    that you did the work.
    You don't get a reminder for oil, and another one for air filter, and
    another one for ATF, etc. You get a reminder with a set of items to
    perform.
    Yes. They say it's based on current and historic usage. I bought my
    08 Fit on March 27th with 11 miles on it (when I did the test drive, I
    put 9 miles on it). Today the MM is showing 10%, A1 service and 5535
    miles. Nasty city/highway mix.
     
    Dillon Pyron, Oct 16, 2008
    #34
  15. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Dillon Pyron Guest

    Actually, by Federal law, they have to show that you voided the
    warranty by not performing the maintenance. You don't have to prove
    that you did the work.
    You don't get a reminder for oil, and another one for air filter, and
    another one for ATF, etc. You get a reminder with a set of items to
    perform.
    Yes. They say it's based on current and historic usage. I bought my
    08 Fit on March 27th with 11 miles on it (when I did the test drive, I
    put 9 miles on it). Today the MM is showing 10%, A1 service and 5535
    miles. Nasty city/highway mix.
     
    Dillon Pyron, Oct 16, 2008
    #35
  16. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Truckdude Guest

    Nothing is going to pop up on its own independent of an oil change.

    The Maintenance Minder system is oil change interval driven based on
    "accumulated engine revolutions and operating conditions." Everything else
    is done in conjunction with oil changes. You will not see a 1 thru 5
    without an A or B.

    Personal adjustment might be necessary for some things other than oil.
    I follow the MM for my oil changes, but I always change the oil filter with
    it.
    Following the MM, my oil changes are every 7000 to 8000 miles so far, but I
    like to rotate my tires every 5,000 miles.
    I just changed my engine air filter with my 15,200 mile oil change because
    it was dirty now, but I probably won't see a 2 code until the next oil
    change.

    I follow the A or B codes strictly, but I consider the 1 thru 5 numeric
    codes as bare minimums if it has not been done already.

    Remember that the computer really only "thinks" about oil life.
     
    Truckdude, Oct 16, 2008
    #36
  17. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Truckdude Guest

    Nothing is going to pop up on its own independent of an oil change.

    The Maintenance Minder system is oil change interval driven based on
    "accumulated engine revolutions and operating conditions." Everything else
    is done in conjunction with oil changes. You will not see a 1 thru 5
    without an A or B.

    Personal adjustment might be necessary for some things other than oil.
    I follow the MM for my oil changes, but I always change the oil filter with
    it.
    Following the MM, my oil changes are every 7000 to 8000 miles so far, but I
    like to rotate my tires every 5,000 miles.
    I just changed my engine air filter with my 15,200 mile oil change because
    it was dirty now, but I probably won't see a 2 code until the next oil
    change.

    I follow the A or B codes strictly, but I consider the 1 thru 5 numeric
    codes as bare minimums if it has not been done already.

    Remember that the computer really only "thinks" about oil life.
     
    Truckdude, Oct 16, 2008
    #37
  18. But didn't you read? He's a self taught EXPERT on such things. Why, he
    knows more in his little finger than all the Honda engineers put
    together. HE knows better.
     
    Elmo P. Shagnasty, Oct 16, 2008
    #38
  19. But didn't you read? He's a self taught EXPERT on such things. Why, he
    knows more in his little finger than all the Honda engineers put
    together. HE knows better.
     
    Elmo P. Shagnasty, Oct 16, 2008
    #39
  20. rev_otis_mcnatt

    Pszemol Guest

    And they show this by me cannot show invoce/recept for the job.
    Custommer cannot show the invoice = > he did not do the maintenance.
    In the warranty contract they make you responsible for doing
    maintenance and keeping all the invoices - you signed the contract.
    How do you supposed to interprete the %%?
    Does it mean only 10% is left or 10% is used and 90% left?
     
    Pszemol, Oct 16, 2008
    #40
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.