Thank You "Elle"

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by Krystyne, Sep 30, 2005.

  1. Krystyne

    Krystyne Guest

    Thanks a million "Elle". I checked my coolant. It was bone dry. I addded
    anti-freeze/water mixture, took a spin around the block. The car is
    running normal. I will check the owner's manual and purge the line as you
    recommended.
    Thanks again.
    Krystyne
     
    Krystyne, Sep 30, 2005
    #1
  2. Krystyne

    Elle Guest

    Neat. But, hey, bone dry? How did this happen?

    Hopefully you mean just the reservoir was bone dry, and that this was due to
    neglect.

    Though I might sound like your mom, again remember to only open that
    radiator cap with the engine stone cold. When warm at all, the radiator
    cooling system is under pressure, and hot fluid will dangerously burst out
    at anyone who takes off the cap. When cool, all is safe.

    Follow the manual's instructions about purging carefully.

    Make sure you use the right coolant, and mix it only with distilled (not
    tap) water.

    Last summer my 1991 Civic was revving like yours. The coolant levels
    appeared fine. But in fact a few months before I had replaced the cooling
    system thermostat and got some air into the system. I did not know how to do
    a proper purge and so hadn't done one after this little repair. Folks here
    helped me figure this out. I learned it would take a long time for the fan
    to come on (something like 3/4 hour) during the purge procedure. It finally
    did, and I added coolant per the purge instructions to get the level
    correct.
     
    Elle, Sep 30, 2005
    #2
  3. Krystyne

    TeGGeR® Guest


    Aha! So it seems that in spite of my experiment in disconnecting the TW
    sensor, and in spite of Misterbeet's assertions, there IS evidence that a
    low coolant level WILL cause a fluctuating idle! VERY cool! (So to speak.)

    Now the question: WHY? jim beam, Misterbeets...?
     
    TeGGeR®, Sep 30, 2005
    #3
  4. Krystyne

    Steve H Guest

    Easy Tegger.

    The coolant temp sensor will get wrong readings from having the air hit it
    rather than coolant.


    --
    Stephen W. Hansen
    ASE Certified Master Automobile Technician
    ASE Undercar Specialist


    http://www.troublecodes.net/technical/
     
    Steve H, Sep 30, 2005
    #4
  5. Krystyne

    jim beam Guest

    check out the sensor in the manual - it's a tiny thermistor embedded in
    a brass stalk that sticks about an inch into the coolant stream. and
    the manual shows it's resistivity curve too - logarythmic. takes very
    little change in temp to make a big change in resistivity and therefore
    a big change in the signal it's sending the ecu.
     
    jim beam, Sep 30, 2005
    #5
  6. Krystyne

    TeGGeR® Guest


    I have a fatory manual, and that's exactly what I thought too, but
    Misterbeets dissuaded me.

    The ECU goes into closed loop ONLY when the coolant is reported as 90C, so
    it would not take much of a drop to convince the ECU the engine is cooler
    than fully-warm.
     
    TeGGeR®, Sep 30, 2005
    #6
  7. -------------------------

    That's what I've been trying to say. . they are 'full immersion'
    sensors. Hold them above a pot of boiling water . . nothing. Dunk them
    in and they act completely different. When the water pump starts
    pumping, one side of the cooing system goes LOW if there's air in there,
    and idle is affected because sensor(s) is now above waterline. Same
    thing when thermostat opens. Air shifts around.

    That's why the manual should have said 'Keep the coolant in the
    reservoir at the MAX' especially because MIN is impossible to see
    without a clean engine compartment and a flashlight (some models).

    'Curly'
     
    'Curly Q. Links', Sep 30, 2005
    #7
  8. Krystyne

    E Meyer Guest

    If you tried to keep it at MAX you would be filling it every day if you
    lived in a place where they have summer (like here in Dallas). Steady state
    for these things is at the MIN line when cold and at the MAX line when hot
    after driving. If you start at MAX or above, the expansion tank dumps the
    excess when the overflow moves into the tank. After the system sucks the
    overflow back in as it cools, the tank will be sitting exactly at the "MIN"
    line every morning, no matter how much you added to it before you drove it.

    If there is air in the system, some of it can burp out through the overflow,
    in which case it will draw down to below MIN when as it cools.

    Every car I have owned in the past 15 years works this way (including cars
    for the teenagers, that comes out to 4 Hondas, 6 Nissans, a Ford, an
    Oldsmobile, and a Mazda). Air in the system will not be introduced by the
    expansion tank as long as you keep it at the MIN line.

    I think the the directions in the user manual match the function of the
    system - keep it at least at MIN and it works as designed.
     
    E Meyer, Sep 30, 2005
    #8
  9. ===========================

    I half-ways agree with what you're saying, but don't confuse pressurized
    reservoirs with (some?) Honda reservoirs. I'm suggesting that people
    (who don't know any better) remove the cap and look down into the
    reservoir (because they can't actually see it from the side). They see
    three ounces of coolant in the bottom and assume it's OK. My CR-v
    'feeds' the reservoir from a snorkel hose that goes thru the top cap,
    and if the rad sucks the reservoir dry, there's always a bit in the
    bottom. Maybe there should have been a 'magic green eye' like they have
    on the battery (or a sensor). . . Easy to see if the reservoir is _too_
    empty. BTW, the service manual says it's normal for the water pump to
    'weep' a bit of coolant, so we can't assume that a Honda never needs to
    be 'topped up'.

    'Curly'
     
    'Curly Q. Links', Sep 30, 2005
    #9
  10. Krystyne

    E Meyer Guest

    I'm not. None of the cars I listed have a pressurized reservoir. The only
    car I ever had that did was a Volkswagen. What a nightmare that was. When
    the car was only 3 years old, the pressure caused the plastic reservoir to
    crack open like an egg.
    I'm not advocating that they never need to be topped up. Normal evaporation
    in the expansion tank will eventually cause it to drop below MIN, even if
    the system is perfect.

    I hear you about seeing the marks on the tank. What are they thinking? I
    have had some success by marking the MIN and MAX lines with a grease pencil
    when the tank is out for cleaning at anti-freeze change time. Usually that,
    in combination with a flashlight, is enough to be able to see the marks once
    its back in there.

    Nissan seems to have given this a little bit more thought. There is about
    1/2 inch of daylight along the side of the radiator on my '02 Pathfinder and
    the tank is mounted such that you can clearly see the marks on the expansion
    tank as well as the level in the washer bottle on the other side if you look
    across the front of the radiator.
     
    E Meyer, Sep 30, 2005
    #10
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.