Why cant Toyota or Honda make a car that drives just like a BMW?

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by elmo, Sep 10, 2003.

  1. elmo

    C.R. Krieger Guest

    No; *you* do. The very *last* car badged 'Chevrolet Nova' was a
    rebadged 4- and 5-door Toyota Corolla (lagging by one model year when
    the cycle changed) and built in California in the Toyota-GM joint
    venture NUMMI plant. Same place as where my old FX-16 (and other
    Corolla FXs) was built. They also did, for one or two years, a
    hotted-up version that was, originally at least, painted black with a
    red beltline stripe all the way around the car and the same 4A-GE 16V
    engine and drivetrain as the FX-16 and the MR-2. Don't go showing
    your ignorance.
     
    C.R. Krieger, Sep 16, 2003
  2. Let's see...

    you work for 8 hours, but they don't count lunch as work, so
    it's really 35 hours they pay you for. Which means you are
    THERE full-time, but get paid as a part-time employee.

    No benefits, to health care, nothing.


    Or, they use the new laws pushed through by Bush to count
    you as a salaried "management" employee and work you for 60+
    hours a week and only pay you for 40. No overtime.

    That's the harsh reality. Employers will screw with you as an
    employee if it saves them $5 a day.
     
    Joseph Oberlander, Sep 16, 2003
  3. I fear you are giving the British motor industry too much credit. I am sure
    it would have collapsed without the Japanese, too...

    What is left of the old British-owned 'volume' manufacturers is called Rover
    and that should have been put out of its misery years ago. Those poor
    sentimental folk at BMW didn't see that.

    DAS
    --
    ---
    NB: To reply directly replace "nospam" with "schmetterling"
    ---
    .......................
    The entire British motor industry almost died forever
    ..........................
     
    Dori Schmetterling, Sep 16, 2003
  4. elmo

    dizzy Guest

    Just say no to drugs.
     
    dizzy, Sep 16, 2003
  5. elmo

    John Stone Guest

    Sorry, without hard facts, it's still just your opinion.

    Yet, my 2000 Odyssey needed a new transmission less than a month after I
    bought it, and I've received 2 recall notices so far on my CRV. Hondas
    aren't infallible. I had plenty of problems with the various ones I owned (6
    and counting). My 78 and 79 Accords rusted before my eyes. My friend's 86
    Accord was better, but pretty shot by '97. He bought a 98 323i and shows no
    sign of getting rid of it anytime soon. I don't think you'd want to ask him
    which company he thinks makes a better car. My wife's '89 Accord needed a
    water pump, a radiator, and a new distributor cap right after the warranty.
    The cap cost $100 plus labor. Etc., etc. Different cars, different
    experiences. Still, I think Honda makes a darn good car with perhaps the
    best value for money in the industry.
    That's not what I said. It isn't a question of defining yourself. It's a
    question of whether you consider driving a pleasure or a chore. I like to
    drive, and it's much harder for me to get pleasure out of driving a
    refrigerator. I can appreciate that my BMW is a beautifully balanced fun to
    drive machine, just as much as I can appreciate the utility of my CRV. But
    there's absolutely no question about which one is a better vehicle for the
    sheer pleasure of driving. BTW, I kept my last BMW (87 325is) for 13 years
    and then gave it to my nephew who drives it every day.

    But the end result is just what I said. All cars-for whatever reason, be it
    competition or technology-are getting better and better.
     
    John Stone, Sep 17, 2003
  6. .. My friend's 86
    Go have a look at a '86 3 series. Plenty of rust.

    At least compare cars of equal *decades*, FFS.
     
    Stephen Bigelow, Sep 17, 2003
  7. elmo

    notbob Guest

    I don't know about that. It's not like the Brits had any real
    competition in their default niche, which was sporty, good handling,
    autos and motorcycles. US stuff was essentially huge tuna boats
    lumbering around on $.27/gal gas and sporty Italian thingies barely
    able to make it from one non-existent repair shop to another. When
    the first Jap stuff hit our shores, Brit motor vehicles were selling
    like hotcakes (at least here in CA) and had no real competition. The
    first thing we did when we got out of high school (or the service) was
    sell off our 3rd and 4th hand American clunkers and moved up to hot
    Brit motorcycles or Brit roadsters.

    But, the writing was on the wall. The bikes were the first to fall.
    How could they compete with Jap bikes that were just as fast at 1/3
    the price? Sure, the Brit bikes were handling thoroughbreds compared
    to the early Nippon slugs, but the price differential was too much.
    No one could compete with Japan's dumping practices. And, as time
    passed, Japanese machinery got better and better. In time they were
    as good as Brit bikes and still cost less. The Brits lost their
    shorts. And a decade later, the Brit auto industry suffered the same
    fate.

    Sure, most of the problem was the Brits hadn't updated a single plant
    or design in decades, and so were caught napping in the Japanese
    design/marketing revolution. And when they finally realized the depth
    of the problem, the powerful labor unions kept them from quickly
    adapting to a rapidly changing market. But, I still maintain that if
    the Japanese hadn't launched an economic attack on the comatose world
    transportation industry, the Brits would have continued for
    considerably longer than they did.

    nb
     
    notbob, Sep 17, 2003
  8. elmo

    MudPuppy Guest

    i finally sold my 1989 camry, with 280,000 miles on it. the only problem
    with it was the rear fenders rusting out.
     
    MudPuppy, Sep 17, 2003
  9. elmo

    Roadie Roger Guest

    Ooh my. Looks just like this one.

    The daily news is rife with
    Move to Cuba. The government guarantees you a job, food and medical
    care. Trading freedom for security sure was a great bargain. Sorry,
    the Soviet Union is no longer an option. Americans are such scaredy
    cat security loving snots. Everything has to be guaranteed and
    insured. The only guarantee you have in life is to starve and be too
    hot or too cold. Life's a bitch, so you should have a little
    compassion for your fellow man. If you want better than that you have
    to get off your butt and work for it. You may lose. That's the way
    it goes.
    That would be to their benefit, wouldn't it?
    Apparently these illegal aliens have no trouble doing the jobs.
    Again, that would be in their benefit, wouldn't it? Human beings are
    tragically flawed and always look out for their own self interest.
    Even if they are in government or labor unions.
    True, see, we agree on lot's of stuff like your keen analysis of
    politicians.

    YOUR statement
    I didn't say they wouldn't. I specifically mentioned their greed.
    When you needed a roof put on, did your hire a 62 year old who can't
    climb a ladder, get him full medical insurance and promise him
    lifetime employment and retirement benefits? I'm sure you did, not
    being a low life hypocrite and all.

    The industrial age is over. Industrial age people will die off and
    new people will take their place. Maybe they will be information
    workers, but I am sure it will be more complicated than that.
    Industrial workers kicked the crap out of agricultural workers (did
    you just work sun up to sun down hand hoeing a wheat field?).
    Agricultural workers kicked the crap out of hunter gatherers.
    Automation means we really don't need everyone to be employed. We can
    hand out 39 weeks unemployment to anyone and there is no lack of goods
    and services. Society is gonna have to adjust. You can spend you
    life being hostile and unhappy because the world doesn't match your
    expectations or you can deal with reality and be happy. I hope you
    choose happy.

    We now have the leisure time to do the only important thing in life:
    Sliding tires on dry pavement in a Honda :)
    Cheers,
    Roadie Roger
     
    Roadie Roger, Sep 17, 2003
  10. elmo

    David Kelly Guest

    Clearly that was due to American Managers in bed with your local
    government conspiring to salt the roads you drive on...
     
    David Kelly, Sep 17, 2003
  11. elmo

    daytripper Guest

    More like a mistake at birth...
     
    daytripper, Sep 17, 2003
  12. elmo

    Philip® Guest

    Where do you think "hard facts" come from? Some website?

    --

    ~~Philip

    "Never let school interfere
    with your education - Mark Twain"
     
    Philip®, Sep 17, 2003
  13. Nope.

    What about paying taxes and going to the loo?

    DAS
    --
    ---
    NB: To reply directly replace "nospam" with "schmetterling"
    ---
    ..........................
    ..........................
     
    Dori Schmetterling, Sep 17, 2003
  14. It seems the British auto industry had already collapsed by the time you
    focussed on it, if you think there was a default niche. Like I said, Rover
    is the remnant of the volume business. Decades ago the level of imports was
    very small. There was a niche only in the sense that very few cars found a
    ready market abroad, a few sales of MGBs and Jags in Europe and California
    notwithstanding. There were many manufacturers, most of whom were forced to
    merge into British Leyland by the government in an effort to stop them going
    under. Now there are niche manufacturers such as Caterham, Bristol, Morgan
    and the like.

    The Mazda MX-5 (Miata) is what the British sports car should have been.
    Fun, relatively inexpensive and RELIABLE.

    DAS
     
    Dori Schmetterling, Sep 17, 2003
  15. elmo

    John Stone Guest

    Well, some websites do have statistics on reliability-JD Power for one, and
    CR for another. I can't see how one person's biased experience can be
    universally applied to all Honda models from all years in all parts of the
    country. My experience with Hondas is mixed, yet I don't conclude anything
    about Hondas in total from this, because my data is insufficient to do so.
     
    John Stone, Sep 17, 2003
  16. elmo

    Philip® Guest

    I thought so. Hard Facts® come from empirical experience. Vehicles
    actually have to be run into concrete barriers, other vehicles, at
    different angles, spun around on a skid pad .... to get real life
    data because computer models do miss mitigating factors, especially
    where operator input occurs. The people who do the "mop up" repairs
    are the ones who know what's worth knowing.
    --

    ~~Philip

    "Never let school interfere
    with your education - Mark Twain"
     
    Philip®, Sep 17, 2003
  17. elmo

    Frank Kemper Guest

    (Phil) hat in Betrag @news.easynews.com dies gedichtet:
    The hardest time for BMW were the years after WWII. They had a capacity
    problem and a model range problem.

    The capacity problem was the fact, that their valuable production
    facilities in Eisenach were seized by the soviet troops and went lost for
    BMW. In the first years of the GDR there were Eisenach made BMW cars
    available in the soviet zone. BMW solved the capacity problem later by
    buying the car manufacturer Glas in Dingolfing. Today mainly the 5-Series
    is made in Dingolfing.

    The second problem of BMW was the odd model lineup in the early 50s. They
    only had extremely expensive super cars like 501/502, 503, 507 or the
    tiny Isetta, which was hardly a car. Nothing to compete with the medium
    class cars made by Borgward, VW, DKW, Ford or Opel. The BMW 700 with rear
    mounted engine was beautiful, but too expensive. Things began to become
    better when they started the BMW 1500, a fast, yet roomy sedan with good
    performance and a reasonable price. The 02 model was a similar concept,
    only with two doors. It became a huge success.

    Frank
     
    Frank Kemper, Sep 17, 2003
  18. elmo

    Philip® Guest

    Could it be said that a person with diarrhea is a "Loo-zer?"
     
    Philip®, Sep 18, 2003
  19. elmo

    fbloogyudsr Guest

    http://catalog.eautopartscatalog.com/buymb/wizard.jsp?partner=buymb&clientid=buyeuroparts&baseurl=http://www.buyeuroparts.com/&cookieid=0TT0PMLOP&year=1991&make=BM&model=525-I-002&category=N&part=Brake+Pad+Set

    Bimmerworld will *not* be getting my business any more!

    Floyd
     
    fbloogyudsr, Sep 18, 2003
  20. elmo

    Guest Guest

    To me, they came very close to the way the 3 series drives with the IS.
    I drove both 3's and IS's before buying my IS, and the handling seemed
    about equal. The 325 is a little slower and the 330 is a little faster
    than the IS300 camparing auto/auto or manual/manual. Both the BMW and
    IS engines are very smooth and nice sounding. The IS seems to have a
    little more road and/or wind noise than the BMW, though.

    I bought my SportCross mainly because it should be more reliable than a
    BMW, and it has been totally trouble-free so far (~20 miles). Also, I
    found a very low mileage, mint condition used one and saved quite a bit
    of money over buying a Bimmer or IS new.

    The thing I wish Toyota had copied more closely from BMW when designing
    the IS is the instruments. They IS instruments are a little too gimicky
    for my tastes. Still, I like the car a lot.
     
    Guest, Sep 22, 2003
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.