windshield defogger -- cool air in warm weather w/o A/C?

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by Paul Stuart, Aug 18, 2003.

  1. Paul Stuart

    Paul Stuart Guest

    When the windshield defogger is operating in my 2003 Accord (on
    a cool temperature setting), and the A/C is apparently off (the
    A/C indicator lamp is unlit), I note that really cool air comes
    out of the upper dash vents even in mid-80s weather. The air is
    so cool, especially when the car's interior is not hot, that I
    find myself not even needing to activate the A/C!

    What is the source of this cool air? Is the A/C system actually
    operating in tandem with the windshield defogger on the cool setting?

    Paul
     
    Paul Stuart, Aug 18, 2003
    #1
  2. Paul Stuart

    BigJohnson Guest

    Yes it is. The purpose being to dehumidify the air.
    Adjust the temperature setting to suit.



    mike hunt
     
    BigJohnson, Aug 18, 2003
    #2
  3. Paul Stuart

    BigJohnson Guest

    Yes it is. The purpose being to dehumidify the air.
    Adjust the temperature setting to suit.



    mike hunt
     
    BigJohnson, Aug 18, 2003
    #3
  4. Paul Stuart

    Larry Guest

    It actually is the reverse........use the recirc air button once the air is
    cold inside the cabin......make the ac work less as it is recirculating
    cooler air. Don't use the recirc button until the air is cool.....and open
    the window for a few moments to have hot air escape faster
     
    Larry, Aug 19, 2003
    #4
  5. Paul Stuart

    Larry Guest

    It actually is the reverse........use the recirc air button once the air is
    cold inside the cabin......make the ac work less as it is recirculating
    cooler air. Don't use the recirc button until the air is cool.....and open
    the window for a few moments to have hot air escape faster
     
    Larry, Aug 19, 2003
    #5
  6. Paul Stuart

    StonyRhoads Guest

    Actually you have it backward. One should run on fresh (outside)
    air to pull in outside air and push out the hot air within, when
    using Air conditioner. Once the vehicle begins to cool, go to
    recirc to re-cool the dehumidified air inside the vehicle. There
    is always an infusion of some outside air in any event. In the
    defrost mode the air source is from outside. If you vehicle has a
    manual recirc/fresh (outside) air controller, the recirc should
    only be used for AC, not heating, or your will build up
    humidity. Read your owners manual for complete instruction of
    the operating of the HVAC system, WBMA


    mike hunt
     
    StonyRhoads, Aug 19, 2003
    #6
  7. Paul Stuart

    StonyRhoads Guest

    Actually you have it backward. One should run on fresh (outside)
    air to pull in outside air and push out the hot air within, when
    using Air conditioner. Once the vehicle begins to cool, go to
    recirc to re-cool the dehumidified air inside the vehicle. There
    is always an infusion of some outside air in any event. In the
    defrost mode the air source is from outside. If you vehicle has a
    manual recirc/fresh (outside) air controller, the recirc should
    only be used for AC, not heating, or your will build up
    humidity. Read your owners manual for complete instruction of
    the operating of the HVAC system, WBMA


    mike hunt
     
    StonyRhoads, Aug 19, 2003
    #7

  8. Good advice.
    Mine says to open a window for sec to dump the hot air, and run the A/C in
    recirc.
    Even says to run in recirc for fast heating, but switch to fresh if things
    begin to fog up.

    1991 Honda Accord Owners Manual
     
    Stephen Bigelow, Aug 19, 2003
    #8

  9. Good advice.
    Mine says to open a window for sec to dump the hot air, and run the A/C in
    recirc.
    Even says to run in recirc for fast heating, but switch to fresh if things
    begin to fog up.

    1991 Honda Accord Owners Manual
     
    Stephen Bigelow, Aug 19, 2003
    #9
  10. Paul Stuart

    Mike S Guest

    Whether you're recirculating air or not, your air conditioning system
    is still working just as hard. Your air conditioner is either on or
    off, there's no (or very little) difference in the amount of work
    required. When you have your internal temperature warm or cold,
    recirculating or not, you're AC system is working just as hard. The
    only way to reduce the amount of fuel consumption is to not use AC.

    If you know how air conditioners work, the COMPRESSOR compresses a gas
    (R134 or equivalent) within the cooling system. It requires energy to
    compress the gas, which is supplied by your engine (via a
    belt/pulley). When this gas is allowed to expand, it gets very cold.
    This entire cycle is contained within it's own system so that gas
    isn't lost.
     
    Mike S, Aug 19, 2003
    #10
  11. Paul Stuart

    Mike S Guest

    Whether you're recirculating air or not, your air conditioning system
    is still working just as hard. Your air conditioner is either on or
    off, there's no (or very little) difference in the amount of work
    required. When you have your internal temperature warm or cold,
    recirculating or not, you're AC system is working just as hard. The
    only way to reduce the amount of fuel consumption is to not use AC.

    If you know how air conditioners work, the COMPRESSOR compresses a gas
    (R134 or equivalent) within the cooling system. It requires energy to
    compress the gas, which is supplied by your engine (via a
    belt/pulley). When this gas is allowed to expand, it gets very cold.
    This entire cycle is contained within it's own system so that gas
    isn't lost.
     
    Mike S, Aug 19, 2003
    #11
  12. Nope. Open the windows and set to fresh air. Once the superhot air has
    left the inside of the car, and the car is at outside temperature, close
    the windows and set to recirculate.

    You need to exhaust the superhot interior air before the A/C can really
    do any good.
     
    Elmo P. Shagnasty, Aug 19, 2003
    #12
  13. Nope. Open the windows and set to fresh air. Once the superhot air has
    left the inside of the car, and the car is at outside temperature, close
    the windows and set to recirculate.

    You need to exhaust the superhot interior air before the A/C can really
    do any good.
     
    Elmo P. Shagnasty, Aug 19, 2003
    #13
  14. Paul Stuart

    civic Guest

    On Tue, 19 Aug 2003 20:24:41 -0400, "Elmo P. Shagnasty"

    <snip>

    Some homes have installed ventilation systems that will exchange
    indoor air with filtered outdoor air at the rate of 350 cubic meters
    per hour.
     
    civic, Aug 20, 2003
    #14
  15. Paul Stuart

    Gus Guest

    The interior of the car is what - 2-3% of the interior volue of your
    house? Plus you have many materials in the car not usually seen in a
    house. I don't think this is a very good comparison. There's also a huge
    difference in how they're expected to operate, e.g., a house may take
    hours to cool, whereas if the car isn't cold in 5 minutes, the %^&$$%^&
    a/c is broken!

    FWIW, everything I've read over the years has recommended opening a
    window and running on RECIRC when starting up a car with a heated
    interior, then closing the window and switching to FRESH. With the
    windows (& moonroof, if present) closed, there isn't much fresh air
    coming in, just equal to what the cabin vents permit to escape
    (otherwise the interior would get pressurized and it would be like scuba
    diving).

    Finally, as the a/c compressor cycles on & off, it's consuming
    significant power only when it's running. The fan runs constantly and
    consumes *much* less power than the compressor.
     
    Gus, Aug 20, 2003
    #15
  16. Paul Stuart

    Gus Guest

    The interior of the car is what - 2-3% of the interior volue of your
    house? Plus you have many materials in the car not usually seen in a
    house. I don't think this is a very good comparison. There's also a huge
    difference in how they're expected to operate, e.g., a house may take
    hours to cool, whereas if the car isn't cold in 5 minutes, the %^&$$%^&
    a/c is broken!

    FWIW, everything I've read over the years has recommended opening a
    window and running on RECIRC when starting up a car with a heated
    interior, then closing the window and switching to FRESH. With the
    windows (& moonroof, if present) closed, there isn't much fresh air
    coming in, just equal to what the cabin vents permit to escape
    (otherwise the interior would get pressurized and it would be like scuba
    diving).

    Finally, as the a/c compressor cycles on & off, it's consuming
    significant power only when it's running. The fan runs constantly and
    consumes *much* less power than the compressor.
     
    Gus, Aug 20, 2003
    #16
  17. There's *always* outside air being brought in, even in recirculate. And
    as for materials in the car, everything in a car is seen in a house.
    The chemical makeup is no different--even the exhaust.

    Speaking of, recirculate minimizes the exhaust you bring through the
    car. That's why Japanese cars have the separate recirc button--Japanese
    law requires it because of the exhaust and pollution issue. American
    cars typically don't have such a button, because nobody ever made them
    have one.


    Have you ever read your owner's manual? What *have* you read that
    recommends the above? It makes no sense, actually, to start out on
    recirculate. You want to cool the car down quickly, which means drawing
    in outside air--which is much cooler and therefore easier for the A/C to
    cool even further--and exhausting the very hot trapped air.


    Right, which is why you open the windows to allow the extra hot trapped
    air to be blown out by outside 90 degree air being drawn in and much
    more efficiently cooled by the A/C. The net effect is that the interior
    cools down MUCH more quickly than if you asked the A/C to start cooling
    the 140 degree interior air.
     
    Elmo P. Shagnasty, Aug 20, 2003
    #17
  18. There's *always* outside air being brought in, even in recirculate. And
    as for materials in the car, everything in a car is seen in a house.
    The chemical makeup is no different--even the exhaust.

    Speaking of, recirculate minimizes the exhaust you bring through the
    car. That's why Japanese cars have the separate recirc button--Japanese
    law requires it because of the exhaust and pollution issue. American
    cars typically don't have such a button, because nobody ever made them
    have one.


    Have you ever read your owner's manual? What *have* you read that
    recommends the above? It makes no sense, actually, to start out on
    recirculate. You want to cool the car down quickly, which means drawing
    in outside air--which is much cooler and therefore easier for the A/C to
    cool even further--and exhausting the very hot trapped air.


    Right, which is why you open the windows to allow the extra hot trapped
    air to be blown out by outside 90 degree air being drawn in and much
    more efficiently cooled by the A/C. The net effect is that the interior
    cools down MUCH more quickly than if you asked the A/C to start cooling
    the 140 degree interior air.
     
    Elmo P. Shagnasty, Aug 20, 2003
    #18
  19. It controls a blend door, which introduces more or less heated air as
    required. The A/C always runs the same.
     
    Elmo P. Shagnasty, Aug 20, 2003
    #19
  20. It controls a blend door, which introduces more or less heated air as
    required. The A/C always runs the same.
     
    Elmo P. Shagnasty, Aug 20, 2003
    #20
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.